Former fisheries chief ‘targeted’ by comments in Dáil and protected disclosures, WRC hears

Civil servants believed Francis O’Donnell ‘had right to go back to previous role’

Francis O'Donnell has said he was entitled to return to his job as regional director, but IFI disputes this. Photograph: Barry Cronin
Francis O'Donnell has said he was entitled to return to his job as regional director, but IFI disputes this. Photograph: Barry Cronin

Officials in the Department of the Environment believed former Inland Fisheries Ireland (IFI) chief executive Francis O’Donnell was “targeted” by means of protected disclosures and comments in the Oireachtas, an employment tribunal has heard.

Denis Maher, a retired civil servant who oversaw IFI for the department, also said senior officials understood that O’Donnell had an entitlement to revert to his previous role after leaving the agency’s top position.

O’Donnell is claiming at the Workplace Relations Commission (WRC) that he was unfairly dismissed by IFI and penalised after making protected disclosures under whistleblower legislation.

He has claimed he was entitled to return to his substantive post as a regional director in IFI, but this is disputed by the agency.

Under questioning by WRC adjudication officer Michael McNamee on Friday, Maher said there were discussions about O’Donnell’s position involving himself and his immediate superior – described at the hearing as the two people charged in the department with overseeing corporate governance for IFI.

Maher said there were discussions around “challenges” to O’Donnell in relation to protected disclosures and matters aired in the Dáil and the Seanad.

“There was a view and discussions that he [O’Donnell] was being targeted by this,” he said.

The feeling in the department at the time, he said, was that O’Donnell was three-and-a-half years into a five-year contract, which was unlikely to be renewed, but that “at least he can revert to his substantive post”.

Maher said he and more senior colleague discussed the matter and agreed that O’Donnell had an entitlement to return to his earlier post based on precedent.

He said a document provided to O’Donnell in 2023 by a human resource executive in IFI outlining that he could return to his previous role – which Maher said he first saw on Thursday – had “copperfastened” this view.

The WRC heard O’Donnell had previously been a river basin director with IFI on a salary linked to assistant principal officer grade in the Civil Service. The five-year chief executive post was linked to the assistant secretary grade, which had a higher salary.

O’Donnell has maintained that his predecessor as chief executive was permitted to go back to another role in the organisation after his term ended.

In cross-examination of Maher, Tiernan Lowey, for the IFI, disputed the idea that O’Donnell had a right to revert to his previous position. He said the situation regarding the predecessor was not an appropriate comparator.

Lowey said O’Donnell’s predecessor had argued under employment legislation that he was entitled to a contract of indefinite duration. Maher disagreed and said the specific issue was over whether he would continue to be paid at chief executive level.

The Department of the Environment and the Department of Public Expenditure would say O’Donnell had no right to revert to his earlier role in IFI, Lowey said. Maher said things may have changed since his retirement in 2024.

Lowey also said his clients would argue that the human resources manager had no authority to send the communication to O’Donnell in 2023 about being permitted to return to his previous post.

Giving evidence for IFI on Friday, a separate former HR executive at the agency, Paula Byrne, who took up her role in 2024, said there was no evidence in any document from the Department of the Environment that O’Donnell had a right to return to another position.

Under cross-examination by O’Donnell, who is representing himself, she said she did not have delegated sanction from the department to appoint new people or change things.

The hearing continues.

  • Join The Irish Times on WhatsApp and stay up to date

  • Sign up for push alerts to get the best breaking news, analysis and comment delivered directly to your phone

  • Listen to In The News podcast daily for a deep dive on the stories that matter

Martin Wall

Martin Wall

Martin Wall is the Public Policy Correspondent of The Irish Times.