UK

‘We cannot afford an uncertain prime minister.’ Sunak narrowly shades heated debate with Starmer

An opinion poll immediately after the first leaders’ debate suggests Sunak had the upper hand

UK prime minister Rishi Sunak and Labour challenger Keir Starmer went head-to-head on over how to boost Britain's economy and the NHS. Video: Reuters
Tue Jun 04 2024 - 23:21

UK prime minister Rishi Sunak and Labour challenger Keir Starmer went head-to-head on Tuesday over how to boost Britain’s economy, with the prime minister accusing the opposition party of wanting to increase taxes if it wins power at a July 4th election.

Both Mr Sunak, a Conservative, and Mr Starmer stuck to their campaign lines in their first debate just weeks before a general election opinion polls suggest Labour is set to win, with Mr Sunak saying only he had a plan to spur Britain’s paltry economic growth and Mr Starmer portraying the Conservatives as presiding over 14 years of economic chaos.

In a heated debate – a recent feature in Britain and one which sees more voters tune into politics – the two leaders battled over how to tackle the cost-of-living crisis, growing waiting lists in the public health service and reducing immigration.

Most of the questions illustrated what many voters are contending with: a cost-of-living crisis when some struggle to pay their household bills, long waits for the health service and lower standards in the education system.

READ MORE

Little new was gleaned from their answers, but an opinion poll taken immediately after the debate suggested Mr Sunak had won the contest.

“Keir Starmer is asking you to hand him a blank cheque when he hasn’t said what he’ll buy with it or how much it’s going to cost you,” Mr Sunak said in his closing comments. “In uncertain times we simply cannot afford an uncertain prime minister.”

Mr Starmer responded saying he would never offer “the gimmicks or unfunded promises that Rishi Sunak does”.

“Imagine how you would feel waking up on July 5th to five more years of the Conservatives, five more years of decline and division, the arsonists handed back the matches,” he said.

“Now imagine turning the page with a Labour government that rolls up its sleeves and gets on with the job... The choice at this election is clear: more chaos with the Conservatives or the chance to rebuild Britain with a changed Labour Party.”

Mr Sunak repeated the Conservatives’ attack line that Labour had no plan for the country beyond putting “everyone’s taxes up by £2,000 pounds”.

“Mark my words, Labour will raise your taxes. It is in their DNA. Your work, your car, your pension, you name it, Labour will tax it,” Mr Sunak said.

Mr Starmer did not deny the charge immediately, but he later called the £2,000 figure “nonsense”. Labour has repeatedly said it will not raise income tax or National Insurance social security contributions if it wins power.

“My dad worked in a factory, he was a toolmaker, my mum was a nurse. We didn’t have a lot of money when I was growing up,” the Labour leader told an audience member who said she was struggling to pay her bills.

“So, I do know the anguish of worrying when the postman comes with a bill, what bill is it, am I going to be able to I pay it? I don’t think the prime minister quite understands.”

Mr Starmer attacked the Conservative Party for presiding over 14 years of chaos and Mr Sunak’s plans to introduce mandatory national service.

The prime minister drew groans when he blamed growing waiting lists at the National Health Service on strikes, and was greeted by laughter when he said the numbers were going down “because they were higher” before.

But he seemed to make up some ground with the audience when discussing how he planned to tackle immigration, portraying his plan to send illegal asylum seekers to Rwanda as a deterrent the Labour Party was lacking and saying he would put the country’s security above any foreign court.

Mr Starmer said he also had a plan to tackle immigration, which has become a prominent concern among voters, and that he would consider processing asylum claims in a third country if doing so didn’t breach international law.

Mr Sunak, whose campaign has yet to reduce Labour’s lead of about 20 percentage points in opinion polls, was on the attack, repeating the line that only his party had a plan, whereas voters did not know what Mr Starmer intended to do if he won power.

The two-way leaders’ debate comes a day after populist Nigel Farage said he was running in the election, a major blow to Mr Sunak with the Brexit campaigner expected to peel off the votes of many right-wing voters.

At an earlier campaign launch, Mr Farage said he would be a thorn in the Conservatives’ – and Labour’s – side.

“I will be unafraid, despite what everybody says, despite what names they call me, they are so stupid it only encourages me really,” he told dozens of supporters in southeastern England. “Send me to parliament to be a bloody nuisance.”