Barrister Emily Egan earns just short of €1m from State

State Claims Agency reveals lists of payments to lawyers and firms for representation

The State Claims Agency paid out just under €4.8m to the top-10-earning barristers in 2016. Photographs: Getty Images

The State Claims Agency paid out just under €4.8m to the top-10-earning barristers in 2016. Photographs: Getty Images

 

One barrister earned nearly €1 million in fees last year for representing the State in High Court actions.

The payments were made by the State Claims Agency, which is responsible for dealing with personal injury and property damage claims taken against 129 State agencies including the Health Service Executive, An Garda Síochána­ and the Irish Prison Service.

In 2016, Emily Egan SC was paid 39 instalments totalling €994,535 by the agency.

More than 10 per cent of the total €9.4 million paid to barristers by the agency went to Ms Egan, who mostly represents the State in medical negligence cases.

The figure dwarves the amount paid by the State to the top-earning criminal barristers. In 2015, the highest-paid criminal prosecutor was Paul O’Higgins SC, who received €449,623.

The highest earner from criminal legal aid was Michael Bowman SC, who received €457,773.

The SCA paid out just under €4.8 million to the top-10-earning barristers in 2016. The second-highest-earning barrister was Declan Buckley SC who earned €886,940. Other high earners include Remy Farrell, who received €211,622, and former attorney general Paul Gallagher, who was paid €134,439.

This is the first time the agency has made available the yearly amount it pays lawyers.

Medical negligence

In total, the State Claims Agency spent €24 million on external legal services, including nearly €15 million paid to 30 solicitors’ firms. The top-five-earning law firms received €10.7 million of the total.

Much of the work and expenditure of the agency is related to medical negligence cases relating to the HSE. The vast majority of these are settled out of court but the cases that do go to court often involved complex and lengthy legal issues.

In 2015, the agency managed 8,725 claims against State bodies, which had an estimated liability of €1.79 billion. More than half of this liability related to maternity services provided by the HSE.

The agency has also had to deal with several mass legal actions in recent years. At least 1,000 prisoners and former prisoners have taken cases against the State alleging breaches of their constitutional rights in relation to in-cell sanitation.

And in the aftermath of the Louise O’Keeffe case at the European Court of Human Rights, at least 233 people have taken claims against the Department of Education alleging they were sexually or physically abused while at school.

Another 266 people with orthopaedic implants have taken claims alleging the implants were improperly fitted, while 40 former and current members of the Defence Forces have sued the State alleging the anti-malarial drug Lariam they were given caused psychosis.

TEN HIGHEST-EARNING LAWYERS HIRED BY STATE TO DEFEND CIVIL CLAIMS IN 2016:

Egan, Emily €994,535

Buckley, Declan €886,940

Egan, Adrienne €596,858

McCullough, Eoin €503,391

Foley, Brian €337,595

Corcoran, Sarah €325,057

Hanratty, Patrick €284,714

Farrelly, Marjorie €284,697

McGinn, Paul €282,977

Dolan, Ronan €277,411

TOP TEN EARNING FIRMS HIRED BY STATE CLAIMS AGENCY FOR LEGAL REPRESENTATION IN 2016:

Mason Hayes Curran €3,096,468

Hayes Solicitors €3,006,387

Ronan Daly Jermyn €2,284,491

Comyn Kelleher Tobin € 1,347,652

Doyle Solicitors €953,191

Arthur Cox** €826,587

A&L Goodbody** €807,001

VP McMullin €473,330

Hegarty & Armstrong Solicitors €368,362

Harrison O’Dowd €342,147