Should I stick with a petrol car or make the switch to electric?

I’m considering replacing my old Volkswagen Passat with a Skoda Octavia or the electric Skoda Elroq

Skoda Elroq
Skoda Elroq: ideal for short city commutes

I was considering replacing my 2011 VW Passat 1.4 TSI with a Skoda Elroq 85 in Selection or Sportline trim. I then saw the spec for the Skoda Octavia 1.5 mHEV in Heritage trim, which turned my head. I have been in (though not driven) both cars, and although I think the Elroq makes perfect sense, I do like the look and feel of the more traditional-looking Octavia. For context, I drive 25km daily in heavy city traffic with the odd country trip. I also have my own driveway. The mpg stated online for my Passat is 42-47, but only 52-54 for the Octavia 1.5 mHEV, which I find confusing. Any direction you could give me would be appreciated.

BC, Co Dublin

Let’s deal with the fuel economy thing first. Are you confused that the Octavia has only slightly better fuel economy than your Passat, and you thought it should be much better? The answer to that is broadly simple but more complex when you start looking deeper under the bonnet.

Much of it is to do with the switch from the old NEDC official fuel economy test to the tougher, arguably more realistic, WLTP test. Because the WLTP test was officially introduced in 2017, it means that the figures you’re looking at for your Passat are likely taken under the old NEDC test, which frankly was so full of holes that a Swiss cheese maker would reject it for being more hole than whole. Car makers ruthlessly exploited these holes to give their cars on-paper figures that could rarely be replicated in the real world.

Hence the surprisingly narrow gap between a new Octavia with a more modern 1.5-litre engine and mild-hybrid assistance and a 15-year-old Passat with a 1.4-litre engine whose design dates further back than that, to about 2005. If you tested the new Skoda on the NEDC system, it would probably get fuel economy north of 65mpg (4.5 litres per 100km) instead of the much more realistic 52mpg (5.4 litres per 100km) quoted in the official figures.

[ How to save on car insurance: Actuaries reveal 10 insider secretsOpens in new window ]

Now, as to which one is better for you. The Octavia is a properly lovely car, and as you say it’s more “traditional”. That can be taken in two ways, I guess, but if traditional means roomy, well-made, good to drive and economical, then frankly I’ll take traditional every day over whatever else is on offer. The Octavia has long been one of the most sensible and all-round excellent cars you can buy, and that hasn’t changed recently.

Given your short daily drive, the 1.5 TSI mHEV – that’s the one with the automatic seven-speed DSG gearbox and mild-hybrid assistance – is definitely the right one to go for, as a diesel engine would make absolutely no sense for you at all (and anyway, shortly you won’t be able to order a new diesel Octavia at all). The Heritage spec you mention is also rather nice, and the optional “Cognac” tan-coloured leather seats really lift the Octavia’s cabin and give it a touch of premium car classiness.

However, you should probably get the Elroq. As you say, your driving pattern is 25km a day in heavy traffic, with the odd jaunt out into the country, and you have your own driveway. Which means you are the perfect person to switch to an electric car.

Let’s run some numbers. If you’re doing 25km a day, I’m assuming that’s weekday commuting, so a five-day working week would add up to 6,500km annually. Let’s knock off 250km for a couple of weeks’ holiday and add on 1,000km for your occasional countryside jaunts and another 1,000km for safety.

[ EV public charging costs now exceeding those for petrol and dieselOpens in new window ]

So we’ll round it up to a notional 8,300km annually. In an Octavia 1.5 mHEV averaging 6.0 litres per 100km (which is 47mpg, which is what you’re likely to average in city traffic) that means you’ll spend about €970 a year on fuel assuming a pump price of around €1.95 a litre for petrol.

Could you save if you switch to the electric Elroq? The €41,595 price tag of the Octavia Heritage 1.5 TSI mHEV gets you into either a Selection spec Elroq with the big 77kWh battery (€41,566), or a Sportline version with the smaller 58kWh battery (€39,977). Personally, I think you should go for the Sportline with the smaller battery, as you simply don’t do enough big-mileage long trips. The Elroq 60 Sportline has an official range of 441km on a full charge, and that means around 350-380km in real-world driving. Which means you’ll be able to cover your notional annual mileage on 23 full charges.

If we assume for a moment that you can get onto an Electric Ireland Home Electric + Night Boost rate and fit a 7kW home charger, you could do all your charging at 18.54c per kWh on the night rate between 11pm and 8am (plenty of time for your smaller battery to charge fully each time) with a bonus 10.88c per kWh between 2am and 4am. That means less than €10 per full charge, or about €230 per year.

Sadly, Skoda doesn’t offer a free home charger at the moment, so you’ll have to pay €1,399 up front to get one of the Ohme chargers that Skoda officially recommends, but again, that will repay itself over time, and you’ll be future-proofing yourself for electric motoring.

The Elroq is also a really nice car, with a high-quality cabin, lots of space and great refinement. It’s ideal for your short commutes and will still be capable of heading off into the country whenever you want to.

[ What became of Ireland’s EV scrappage scheme?Opens in new window ]

However, there’s a final wrinkle here, and it depends on if you’re buying on finance. Right now, Skoda has a special offer for the Elroq with 1.9 per cent APR interest finance on a PCP deal. Which sounds good, until you realise that there’s a 0 per cent finance offer available for the Octavia, which works out about €30 a month cheaper over three years. That’s enough to wipe out the savings you’ll make on fuel.

So, the final advice is – if you’re paying cash, get the Elroq. If you’re buying on finance, go for the Octavia.