Fianna Fáil accused of attempt to divert attention from Jim O’Callaghan with CCPC request

Matt Carthy says seeking competition watchdog’s views on legal aid dispute is a diversion

Sinn Féin justice spokesman Matt Carthy. Photograph: Dara Mac Dónaill/The Irish Times
Sinn Féin justice spokesman Matt Carthy. Photograph: Dara Mac Dónaill/The Irish Times

A request for the views of the competition watchdog on the legal aid dispute is an attempt by Fianna Fáil to divert attention away from Minster for Justice Jim O’Callaghan, Sinn Féin’s justice spokesman Matt Carthy has claimed.

This suggestion has been rejected by Anne Rabbitte – the Fianna Fáil Senator who requested that the Competition and Consumer Protection Commission (CCPC) be contacted by the Oireachtas Justice Committee on the matter.

On Tuesday, a public meeting of the committee heard from lawyers who are concerned about O’Callaghan’s changes to the legal aid scheme which has led to some solicitors withdrawing their services in protest.

During a private session afterwards, the committee agreed to write to the CCPC seeking its views.

The committee’s chairman, Carthy, has said he has “no difficulty” with the letter being sent to the CCPC. However, he also argued that it is “an attempt by Fianna Fáil to divert attention away from the Minister [O’Callaghan] who has implemented a scheme that has caused huge disruption”.

Rabbitte disputed this claim, insisting that rather than a co-ordinated attempt with party colleagues to seek the sending of the letter, “I single-handedly did it myself”. She also said the justice committee “agreed unanimously” to send the letter.

The new €520 flat-fee payment model for legal aid, based on an average five appearances, replaced the existing appearance-based scheme, involving €240 for the first appearance and €60 for every subsequent one.

O’Callaghan maintains the old system incentivised adjournments and was open to abuse. Solicitors dispute this and saying the new model means they are expected to work for free on complex cases requiring multiple court appearances.

During Tuesday’s public meeting of the Justice Committee, Rabbitte asked solicitors whether the withdrawal of services breached competition law. In asking the question she referenced a fictional example of an anti-competitive boycott published on the CCPC website in 2009 that coincidently featured a dispute over legal aid.

[ Finland cut homelessness by 80 per cent with housing-first policy, Irish conference hearsOpens in new window ]

In response, Tony Collier, a partner in Ferrys LLP, told Rabbitte that solicitors are not compelled to work under the criminal legal aid scheme, that they had withdrawn their services on an individual basis, and “have not come together as a collective”.

It is understood that the letter being sent by the committee to the CCPC references Rabbitte’s contribution to the meeting and seeks any observations the commission may have on the issues raised during the engagement.

A spokeswoman for O’Callaghan said his office has been in contact with the clerk of the justice committee in recent weeks to confirm the minister will attend a committee meeting in October and “a date is currently being finalised”.

A CCPC statement said the commission is “aware of the continuing dispute concerning changes to the criminal legal aid scheme.

“As an enforcement body, we would be unable to comment on whether we’re considering investigating a specific company, organisation or practice.

“We are aware of media reports that say the Committee on Justice, Home Affairs and Migration intends to write to the CCPC. When they do, we will respond in due course.”

[ Unrest, confusion and conflict in Coalition over sports capital grant announcementOpens in new window ]

In response to a query about the Justice Committee’s letter to the CCPC a Law Society statement said: “The Law Society is conscious at all times of its legal obligations, including under competition law, and has received expert advice on this matter. The Law Society has not recommended to its members that they behave in any particular way. It is a matter for individual solicitors to make their own decisions.”

  • Join The Irish Times on WhatsApp and stay up to date

  • Listen to our Inside Politics podcast for the best political chat and analysis

  • Get the Inside Politics newsletter for a behind-the-scenes take on events of the day

Cormac McQuinn

Cormac McQuinn

Cormac McQuinn is a Political Correspondent at The Irish Times