Sir, – A judge’s comparison of people who challenged a wind farm in court to a soldier still fighting a war that ended long ago deserves more than a passing wince (“Judge compares wind farm objectors to ‘dogged Japanese soldier’ still fighting second World War”, News, October 4th).
The objectors were not fighting an obsolete war. The judge upheld their challenge on the freshwater pearl mussel and the kingfisher, but accepted that the planning commission’s errors made no difference and refused to overturn the planning permission.
Even so, these one-shot litigants merit support, not scorn. Nature cannot go to court. It depends on ordinary people willing to ask difficult questions before irreversible damage is done. This voluntary effort is not done lightly.
Ireland spends less of its economy on environmental protection than any other EU country. Ninety per cent of its protected habitats are in unfavourable condition. And this year the European Commission opened infringement proceedings over its marine nature sites.
READ MORE
With the State’s duty of care for nature so poorly met, community groups have every reason to be a stone in the shoe of the planning commission and the Minister for the Environment.
Ridicule by a judge, in this climate, risks a chilling effect on community groups prepared to uphold environmental law and on public confidence that the courts are open to all.
We must soldier on regardless. – Yours, etc,
OLIVIA CAFOLLA,
Co Wicklow.











