South Africa make Ireland Under-20s pay for imprecision

Number eight Caelan Doris gives fine showing in an otherwise scrappy performance

Ireland U-20 17 South Africa U-20 30

A second defeat for Ireland in the Under-20 World Championship and this one will hurt for a different reason to the opening day loss to France. The Irish team will be disappointed with the imprecision that dogged their play in the opening half an hour and the concession of a couple of soft tries that handed South Africa an early ascendancy on the scoreboard.

Noel McNamara's side did fight back from 12-0 down to lead 17-12 early in the second half, primarily through the excellence of their outstanding number eight and captain Caelan Doris, but being penalised half a dozen times at the scrum provided South Africa with a platform to dominate possession and territory after the interval.

South African centre Wandisile Simelane crossed for three tries after the re-start as Ireland ran out of steam in the final quarter, courage not enough to stave off another defeat. They will face Georgia in their final pool match hoping to secure a win that would allow them to compete for fifth to eighth places in the crossover phase of the tournament.


Ireland's periodic sloppiness first surfaced with the game just 28 seconds old when scrumhalf Johnny Stewart had his clearance kick charged down by his opposite number Zak Burger, the South African quickest to react and dot down for the first try of the game. Damian Willemse added the conversion.

A failure to execute the basics permeated all aspects of Ireland's play - patterns, handling errors, conceding penalties and turnovers at the set piece or scrum and lineout, some poor kicking and wayward passing - but despite these handicaps, and Tom Roche losing control of the ball over the South African line in first half injury time, Noel McNamara's side still managed to rescue a poor start and dominate possession.

Trailing 12-0 after conceding a second try to Muller du Plessis, Ireland struck back initially through a Conor Dean penalty and then a try from the outstanding Doris, converted by the outhalf to leave them trailing 12-10 at the interval.

In Doris, O'Brien, Dean and Michael Silvester, they had players who put a bit of shape on Ireland's attacking patterns and provide momentum while Jack Dunne was outstanding up front.

Ireland cut down on the errors, dominated possession and forced their opponents into conceding a rake of penalties and losing a player to the sin bin.

Dean landed a 30-metre penalty and then tagged on a conversion to a fine try from Doris off a five metre scrum. Ireland could have gone in ahead at the break but Roche lost control in the tackle as he went to ground the ball one-handed over the line.

Ireland's captain and number eight made two brilliant breaks early in the second half and from the second Michael Silvester finished beautifully. Dean converted to nudge Ireland 17-12 in front but a brace of tries for South African centre Simelane changed the complexion of the match. Fullback Gianni Lombard kicked a penalty to put the 'Baby Boks' two scores ahead.

Simelane grabbed his hat-trick of tries with four minutes remaining, the physical wear and tear taking a huge toll on Ireland in the final quarter.

Scoring sequence - 1 min: Burger try, Willemse conversion, 0-7; 19: du Plessis try, 0-12; 22: Dean penalty, 3-12; 34: Doris try, Dean conversion, 10-12. Half-time: 10-12. 43: Silvester try, Dean conversion, 17-12; 51: Simelane try, 17-17; 57: Simelane try, 17-22; 68: Lombard penalty, 17-25; 76: Simelane try, 17-30.

South Africa U-20: Gianni Lombard (Lions); Tyrone Green (Lions), Wandisile Simelane (Lions), Lyle Hendricks (Western Province), Muller du Plessis (Sharks); Damian Willemse (Western Province), Zak Burger (Sharks); Nathan McBeth (Lions), Daniel Jooste (Western Province), Asenathi Ntlabakanye (Lions); Salmaan Moerat (Western Province, capt), Ruan Nortje (Blue Bulls); Dian Schoonees ( Lions), Ben-Jason Dixon (Western Province), Muller Uys (Western Province). Replacements: Schalk Erasmus (Western Province) for Jooste 26 mins; PJ Steenkamp (Lions) for Nortje 28-50 and 61 mins; Lulbabalo Dobela (Free State) for du Plessis half-time; Manuel Rass (Lions)for Willemse 49 mins; Alulutho Tshakweni (Eastern Province) for McBeth 61 mins; Sazi Sandi (Western Province) for Ntlabakanye 61 mins; Steenkamp for Dixon 61 mins; Jooste for Erasmus 68 mins; , Ruan Vermaak (Lions) for Steenkamp 72 mins. IRELAND U-20: M Silvester (Dublin University); T Roche (Lansdowne), T O'Brien (UCD), J Hume (Banbridge), S O'Brien (Clontarf); C Dean (St Mary's College), J Stewart (QUB); J Duggan (Naas), D Barron (Garryowen), J Aungier (St Mary's College), C Daly (Clontarf), J Dunne (Dublin University), J Dunleavy (Malone), M Agnew (Ballymena), C Doris (S. Mary's College, capt). Replacements: A Hall (Ballynahinch) for Dunleavy 54 mins; H O'Sullivan (Clontarf) for Stewart 59 mins; J Byrne (Dublin University) for Aungier 59 mins; D Sheehan (Dublin University) for Barron 63 mins; J McCarthy (UL Bohemian) for Silvester 65 mins; H Byrne (UCD) for Dean 68 mins; B O'Connor (UCC) for Duggan 70 mins.

Referee: D Murphy (Australia)

Yellow card: PJ Steenkamp (South Africa) 39 mins.