Tipperary bringing motion to Congress seeking to define ‘melee’

County unhappy with fallout from incident involving Jason Forde and Davy Fitzgerald

The fallout from the Davy Fitzgerald and Jason Forde incident during Tipperary's league semi-final clash with Wexford looks set to continue into 2018 with the Premier County proposing a law change to deal with such rows.

Tipperary GAA secretary Tim Floyd will have his say at the 2018 GAA Congress after his motion aiming to define a melee was passed at the county's convention over the weekend.

Floyd tabled the motion through his club, Newport, based on the difficulty he had experienced dealing with the GAA disciplinary system when representing Tipperary hurler Forde over the summer.

Forde was first landed with a two-game ban for assaulting an opposition mentor following his on-field clash with Wexford manager Fitzgerald, but, after the charge was struck out on appeal, the lesser charge of ‘contributing to a melee’ was handed to the Silvermines club man.


Fitzgerald was handed an eight-week touchline ban for his part in the clash during April’s league quarter-final between Tipperary and Wexford at Wexford Park, but was permitted to be involved from the stands.

At Forde's Central Appeals Committee hearing, Floyd contested the definition of a melee, and speaking to delegates during the Tipperary convention he said it was his opinion that the committee's definition of two or more players was 'made up on the spot'.

“It is as a result of the hearing that we had in Croke Park this year in relation to the Jason Forde disciplinary decision. I just felt we were hard done by saying that he contributed to a melee,” said Floyd.

Five or more

“We asked how many was involved in a melee and they said at least two. That suited them on that occasion. We want it defined.

“You are wasting your time going to Croke Park or going anywhere for hearings if they make it up on the spot that a melee is more than two people. I don’t think that’s acceptable and that’s the reason we put in the motion.”

There was some opposition to the motion and Tipperary referee co-ordinator, Jim O’Shea, voiced concerns about how the proposed rule change would be policed.

“I have been approached by several referees who have a problem with the wording of this. If it defined as five the fear is there that you won’t be able to act if there is only four involved,” said O’Shea.

Despite O’Shea’s concerns the motion was overwhelming supported by club delegates and it will now be put to Congress. Floyd welcomed the support of the clubs.

“I’m happy that the motion was supported,” he said. “It doesn’t define it in the rule book and for GAA purposes I feel it should be stated. At least if there was a number on it, say five or more.

“I was told at the hearing that anything more than two was a melee, which I find very hard to believe. It makes a bit of a joke of it.

“We have also amended the motion to say that a melee includes persons and not just players, so it will take in anyone that’s at a match.

“We can have more than players involved in melees as we all know”.