Following the publication of Fine Gael’s blueprint for a united Ireland, Tánaiste Simon Harris has written to every party leader on the island inviting them to “meaningful and respectful engagement”.
For most leaders in Northern Ireland, responding has been straightforward. Sinn Féin and the SDLP welcomed the opportunity, while all three unionist parties told Harris to get stuffed. Challenged by nationalists on the robustness of his reply, UUP leader Jon Borrows told Harris to get stuffed a second time. Everyone enjoyed themselves enormously, especially those claiming to be furious.
Alliance was the exception, caught awkwardly in the middle. Questioned by the BBC on Sunday, leader Naomi Long said her party would “engage constructively” on practical co-operation “without prejudice to how we might decide the constitutional question”.
This was immediately condemned by nationalists for evasiveness and by unionists for indulging nationalism. Although Harris could scarcely have left Long off his mailing list, he inevitably set Alliance up to be squeezed between orange and green.
READ MORE
The Drumcree dispute has been applying similar pressure, with Long’s party under fire from unionists and nationalists for not taking a side.
Alliance was supposed to be leading Northern Ireland into a different era. In 2019, its vote doubled to 17 per cent in council, European and Westminster elections as the public rejected a Sinn Féin and DUP deadlock that had collapsed devolution.
[ What’s in Fine Gael’s plan for a united Ireland?Opens in new window ]
In the Assembly election three years later, with devolution stalled again by a DUP walkout, Alliance doubled its seats to become Stormont’s third-largest party, holding the balance of power between nationalist and unionist blocs. It was imagined both blocs would have to woo Alliance to get anything done, drawing politics into the centre ground. Yet there has been a sense of decline ever since, with Alliance slipping steadily to 9 per cent in the polls, back to the minor party level it held for decades.
The balance of power is a weak concept under powersharing. Stormont’s rules are based on unionists and nationalists vetoing or agreeing with each other, and what they have agreed about Alliance is that it is in their way. Unionism lost its Assembly majority in 2022; taking votes from Alliance might get it back. Nationalism is within two seats of unionism. Taking votes from Alliance could make it the largest designation. The race to pick Alliance apart has intensified as the stakes have risen. Polls show the gap between unionism and nationalism narrowing, along with the gap between support for the union or a united Ireland – just 4 per cent in a poll last month.
In Northern Ireland, people can be constitutional liberals and economic or social conservatives. Alliance spanned this range well for most of its history, when it could have been described – not unkindly – as bourgeois. It still allows its assembly members conscience votes on abortion. However, as it has grown it has become a more conventionally liberal and even progressive party, driven by new members and representatives. That has made it a clearer target for political rivals. Unionists have mounted a culture war offensive, accusing Alliance of wokery on gender issues, education and the environment.
[ Fine Gael should have followed Brian Cowen’s cheesy wisdom about unityOpens in new window ]
Nationalists have not thanked Alliance for moving on to their liberal patch – this has only sharped electoral rivalry and jibes about constitutional fence-sitting. After its landmark assembly election in 2022, Alliance has had a lacklustre spell in office. The first two years were wasted by the DUP walkout. When devolution was restored, Alliance chose to enter the executive instead of leading the opposition. It was entitled to two departments and used up one by letting Sinn Féin and the DUP appoint Long as justice minister, an outdated convention to placate unionists by keeping the post neutral. Most aspects of the justice system are autonomous so its minister struggles to make a public impression.
Alliance had no choice for its second department – it was rumoured to want infrastructure but only agriculture was left.
Stormont’s agriculture portfolio includes the environment, a poacher and gamekeeper remit that has pitted the Minister, Andrew Muir, against farmers as he has tried to tackle agricultural pollution and the crisis in Lough Neagh. While not all of this is Alliance’s fault, there has been a lack of strategic thinking on how deal with it.
Economic growth and cross-Border co-operation offer a way out. Fine Gael may have associated these goals with a united Ireland but Alliance could pursue them as practical gains for everyone, compatible with unionist and nationalist aspirations. There is a gap in the market for a pro-growth, pro-business party at Stormont. The DUP likes to claim that mantle but Brexit and the Renewable Heat Incentive destroyed what credibility it had. Alliance could tone down the progressivism and dip a toe back in bourgeois waters. The conversation it might want to have with Harris is how to take a party back to its traditional roots.










