Timeline of national children’s hospital development

From first proposal in 1993 to present day controversy over escalating costs

 

1993: A single, tertiary children’s hospital for Dublin is proposed by the Royal College of Physicians of Ireland. It recommended the centre be built on an adult hospital site.

2005: Then minister for health Mary Harney initiates a review of tertiary paediatric hospital services in September.

HSE chief executive Prof Brendan Drumm says a new children’s hospital “should ideally be in the city centre or close to the Mater site”.

2006: The McKinsey report recommends a single national children’s hospital, into which the three existing children’s hospital in Dublin would be merged.

A HSE taskforce picks the Mater campus as the site of the hospital in June and this is endorsed by government. There are many objections by interest groups to the site.

At the unveiling of the model of the Development Control Plan for the Mater & Children’s Hospital Developments which will create a new hospital campus in 2001. From left: Laura Magahy, Sr Helena O’Donoghue, Micheál Martin Martin Cowley
At the unveiling of the model of the Development Control Plan for the Mater & Children’s Hospital Developments which will create a new hospital campus in 2001. From left: Laura Magahy, Sr Helena O’Donoghue, Micheál Martin Martin Cowley

2007: Then minister for health Mary Harney establishes the National Paediatric Hospital Development Board (NPHDB) for the development of the hospital.

2010: First NPHDB board chair Philip Lynch resigns in October.

2011: Second NPHDB chair John Gallagher resigns in March.

Then minister for health James Reilly announces an independent team to review site decision in May. It reports the correct site was chosen. A planning application is submitted.

Eilish Hardiman, CEO Children’s Hospital Group, and Sean Mahon, lead architect, at the briefing on the New Children’s Hospital, in Dublin in 2010. Photograph: Eric Luke
Eilish Hardiman, CEO Children’s Hospital Group, and Sean Mahon, lead architect, at the briefing on the New Children’s Hospital, in Dublin in 2010. Photograph: Eric Luke

2012: An Bord Pleanála refuses planning permission. The board said the proposed development would “constitute overdevelopment”. About €35 million spent so far will be written off.

Mr Reilly establishes the Dolphin Group to review the issue. On receiving its report, Mr Reilly announces St James’s Hospital as the new site. Critics say the site is too small, with poor access for traffic.

2015: After considerable delay, a planning application is lodged in August. Estimated price is €650 million and completion date is 2020.

Taoiseach Leo Varadkar and Minister for Health Simon Harris mark the commencement of construction. Photograph: Dara Mac Donaill
Taoiseach Leo Varadkar and Minister for Health Simon Harris mark the commencement of construction. Photograph: Dara Mac Donaill

2016: An Bord Pleanála grants planning permission for the project on a 12-acre site in the grounds of St James’s Hospital, together with satellite clinics in Tallaght and Blanchardstown.

External design of the new children’s hospital is unveiled
External design of the new children’s hospital is unveiled

2017: The Government approves a construction budget of €983m for the hospital in April. In August, the NPHDB is told costs have gone up by €200 million. The Department of Health was told of concerns over costs on August 24th and Minister for Health Simon Harris was told on August 27th.

Mr Harris and his officials, and Minister for Public Enterprise Paschal Donohoe and his officials, learn in early November that the cost has now increased by €450 million.

In December, the Government decides to proceed with the project at the increased price. The Irish Times reveals the cost of construction has now increased to €1.43 billion, and overall costs – including equipping and integration, to €1.73 billion.

2019: The Oireachtas health committee and the Dail public accounts committee begin separate investigations into the cost overrun. Consultants PWC are engaged to review the issue. Tom Costello becomes the third chair of the NPHDB to resign. The Government promises to amend the terms of reference of the PWC review to individual accountability can be identified.