The Irish Times view on the Shenzhen summit: Putin the big winner

Russian leader left China confident in the friendship of the two most powerful men in the world

US president Donald Tp poses for a group porumrtrait with president Xi Jinping of China and president Vladimir Putin of Russia. Photo:Doug Mills/The New York Times
US president Donald Tp poses for a group porumrtrait with president Xi Jinping of China and president Vladimir Putin of Russia. Photo:Doug Mills/The New York Times

At just 90 minutes, it was not a second Yalta, the eight-day conference at the end of the second World War that saw Roosevelt, Stalin and Churchill determine the new global order. But Thursday’s meeting in Shenzhen between Donald Trump, Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin did, as the American president observed, make history.

It was the first time the leaders of the world’s three big nuclear powers met in a trilateral format and Trump was determined nuclear disarmament should be on the agenda. The others went along, with Xi describing nuclear weapons as a sword of Damocles hanging over humanity and calling for the entire global arsenal to be eliminated.

Putin also supported a dialogue on the issue, although it is Russia’s nuclear weapons that secured him a place at the top table with the leaders of the world’s two biggest economies. And despite his record of using war as an instrument of state, the Russian president joined Xi and Trump in issuing a four-point declaration towards peace.

The declaration expressed support for reforming the UN; increasing the supply of refined petroleum products; curbing the power of the International Criminal Court; and reducing the nuclear risk. The leaders set no date for their next meeting but all three stressed the importance of communication between the great powers.

The four meetings in the past year between Xi and Trump have eased trade tensions between the US and China in a way that benefits the global economy, even if the future of the trade truce is uncertain. But the inclusion of Putin and Trump’s description of the Russian president as “my friend” will create unease among Washington’s allies, especially in Europe.

Trump discussed the war in Ukraine during a bilateral meeting with Putin and expressed confidence in the Russian leader’s determination to end it. But speaking to reporters in Shenzhen, Putin vowed to retaliate with force against Ukraine for this week’s strikes on the Crimean bridge.

He said he would invite European leaders to Moscow, acknowledging that they were a necessary part of any resolution of the conflict. But Europe is divided over how to approach the negotiations and some leaders are more open to compromise with the Kremlin than others.

The meeting enhanced Xi’s status as a world leader and showcased the success of China’s development model in Shenzhen, a fishing town of 30,000 in the 1970s that is now home to 18 million people. It may have offered Trump a welcome distraction from his domestic political setbacks but the real winner was Putin, who left China affirmed, emboldened, and confident in the friendship of the two most powerful men in the world.