Four jockeys cleared

The appeals of the jockeys that have become known as the "Limestone Lad Four" were successful at the Turf Club yesterday.

The four riders - Charlie Swan, Conor O'Dwyer, Paul Carbery and Pat Malone - had been fined £250 and ordered to forfeit their riding fees over their performances behind Limestone Lad at Leopardstown on December 28th.

On that occasion, the hot favourite, Limestone Lad, was controversially allowed to race clear throughout the three miles of the Woodies Christmas Hurdle.

However, yesterday's appeal resulted in the four jockeys having their fines rescinded, their riding fees returned and also their deposits.

The appeals, which were held collectively, began at 10.45 yesterday morning and the deliberations finished 90 minutes later. The four emerged smiling and less than five minutes afterwards were informed of the Appeals Board's verdict. "We had a very fair hearing and we are happy with the outcome," said Swan.

The jockeys were represented by solicitor Andrew Coonan, who pointed to the length of yesterday's appeal compared to the 15 minutes the racecourse stewards took to originally impose the fines.

"It reflects the fact that everyone had a chance to present a full case," said Coonan. "The cold light of day is always very helpful compared to the pressure at the races. There was additional information available such as handicap ratings and evidence from the trainers."

Evidence was also heard from the handicapper, Noel O'Brien, and the starter on the day at Leopardstown, Joe Banahan.

Ger Lyons, who trained O'Dwyer's mount in the race, Spirit Dancer, was also present and said: "It's been a waste of a morning. Commonsense has prevailed, but it's sad that we've had to come here."