Cuomo criticises Trump after claim protester ‘fell harder than was pushed’

US president’s suggestion it ‘could be a set-up’ called ‘disgusting’ by New York governor

US president Donald Trump: claimed – without offering any evidence – that Mr Gugino may have been attempting to infiltrate police scanners. Photograph: Doug Mills/New York Times

New York governor Andrew Cuomo on Tuesday said he was "disgusted" by US president Donald Trump's claim that a 75-year-old man seen in video being pushed by a Buffalo police officer during a protest "fell harder than (he) was pushed."

“President Trump did a tweet today that surprises me even after all the tweets he has done,” Mr Cuomo said at his daily news briefing.

Mr Trump has claimed a 75-year-old man who was hospitalised when police shoved him to the ground at a protest in Buffalo could be “an antifa provocateur” and suggested the incident “could be a set-up”.

Two Buffalo police officers were charged with assault after video showed them pushing Martin Gugino, a slightly built septuagenarian and longtime peace activist, with enough force that he violently struck his head on the sidewalk.


The New York governor, Andrew Cuomo, responded to Mr Trump’s claims, which were offered without evidence on Tuesday, describing the president’s behaviour as “cruel and reckless”.

“The man is still in the hospital & the president is disparaging him,” Mr Cuomo said.

The incident has been held up as an example of aggressive policing at George Floyd protests across the country and has triggered outrage across the US and overseas.

Mr Trump, however, claimed – without offering any evidence – that Mr Gugino may have been attempting to infiltrate police scanners. The president also seemed to suggest Gugino had exaggerated the force used by police.

“Buffalo protester shoved by Police could be an Antifa provocateur,” Mr Trump said on Twitter.

“75 year old Martin Gugino was pushed away after appearing to scan police communications in order to black out the equipment. I watched, he fell harder than was pushed. Was aiming scanner. Could be a set up?”

Mr Gugino's attorney, Kelly Zarcone, told WBFO News on Tuesday that the 75-year-old has been taken out of intensive care but is "still hospitalised and truly needs rest".

‘Peaceful protester’

“Martin has always been a peaceful protester because he cares about today’s society,” Ms Zarcone said.

“We are at a loss to understand why the president of the United States would make such dark, dangerous and untrue accusations against him.”

Mr Trump tagged One America News Network, a far-right conservative news network, in the tweet. Shortly before Mr Trump’s post, OANN ran a segment which made near identical claims to Mr Trump.

OANN, which has spread multiple conspiracy theories, cited the Conservative Treehouse, a conspiracy theory website, as its source.

The Conservative Treehouse, which is among the news sites listed in’s “misinformation directory”, claimed over the weekend that Mr Gugino “was attempting to capture the radio communications signature” when he was shoved to the ground by the police.

During the 2016 presidential election the Conservative Treehouse peddled the conspiracy theory that Hillary Clinton might have cancer. It has also spread conspiracy theories about student David Hogg, who survived the Parkland school shooting and has become a prominent gun control activist.

“The president is tweeting conspiracy theories about the Buffalo incident based on no evidence, no proof,” Mr Cuomo said.

“Was the blood coming out of his head staged? Were our eyes lying to us? No.”

Mr Cuomo added: “It’s cruel and reckless.”

The two Buffalo officers who pushed Gugino were charged with second-degree assault. All 57 members of Buffalo police’s emergency response team resigned from the team in an apparent show of support for their two colleagues.

Mr Trump announced he would designate antifa – the term stands for anti-fascist – as a terrorist group at the end of May. Experts said the proposal is unworkable, and have said there is no actual antifa organisation to be defined in such terms.

In reality, antifa relates to a broad spectrum of left-wing groups which are opposed to fascism and the far right.

Mr Trump has often embraced conspiracy theories, most notoriously his pushing of "birtherism" – the completely false and racist theory that former president Barack Obama was not born in the US. – Guardian/Reuters