John Redmond’s spirit of pragmatic persuasion is in short supply
London Letter: Small but diverse group marks Irish politician’s centenary in Westminster
John Redmond addressing a Home Rule meeting at the Parnell monument on O’Connell Street in Dublin in March 1912. Photograph courtesy National Library of Ireland
It was a small group that gathered in a committee room at Westminster on Wednesday evening to mark the centenary of John Redmond’s death, but a distinguished and politically diverse one. Northern Ireland secretary Karen Bradley was there, along with two of her predecessors, Theresa Villiers and Paul Murphy.
Her Labour shadow Owen Smith led a contingent from his party that included Vernon Coaker, Stephen Pound, Karen Smith and Alf Dubs. Non-parliamentarians included Ireland’s ambassador Adrian O’Neill and the embassy’s political counsellor Gerald Angley, as well as Christopher Moran, chairman of Co-operation Ireland.
The event was hosted by Conor McGinn, the Newry-born Labour MP for St Helens North, and Jeffrey Donaldson, the DUP’s chief whip at Westminster. The speakers were Redmond biographer Dermot Meleady and Ireland’s pre-eminent living Redmondite, former taoiseach John Bruton.
It felt right that Redmond should be remembered in the place where he spent almost four decades as an MP, from 1881 until 1918. He worked as a clerk at Westminster before his election, and his father and his uncle had both held seats here.
The event was a celebration of Redmond as a parliamentarian by today’s generation in Parliament who have grappled a century later with the relationships between Ireland and Britain and between two traditions in Ireland.
Delayed by debate
Some of the MPs were late, delayed by a debate on extending the Armed Forces Covenant, which protects the rights of British service personnel, to Northern Ireland. As a party leader who imposed strict discipline on his members to maximise their influence in the House, Redmond would have approved of the tardy MPs’ priorities.
“Such was John Redmond’s success that the Daily Mail, with its characteristic understatement when it comes to Irish matters, described him as ‘the Dictator from Dublin’. He had to exert discipline in his party, and recent academic analysis shows the Irish Party to have been the most active, disciplined and cohesive party in the House,” Bruton said.
Both Meleady and Bruton praised Redmond’s combination of political talent and a capacity for compromise which led Parliament to enact Home Rule for Ireland in September 1914. Two years later, he reached an agreement with the Unionist leader Edward Carson that allowed for a provisional partition of the island.
With the DUP and Sinn Féin deadlocked at Stormont and Britain and Ireland at loggerheads over Brexit, Redmond’s spirit of pragmatic persuasion is in short supply today. In a generous speech, Donaldson acknowledged that both sides in Northern Ireland could learn from the example of Redmond.
“I don’t think either side has covered themselves in glory when it comes to persuasion,” he said.
Poison of Brexit
It’s hard to keep the poison of Brexit out of any conversation in Westminster these days, although Bruton introduced the subject in a light-hearted way, noting that one of the big controversies surrounding Home Rule was about whether the Home Rule government would have power to set and collect customs duties, as well as other taxes.
Redmond is a better model for a 21st-century world than are those who did not accept the necessity for compromise
“In other words, would Home Rule Ireland leave the UK customs union, or not? Just as the UK is now finding that leaving the EU customs union has costs as well as benefits, Redmond found that leaving the UK customs union, 100 years ago, would not have been without political difficulty,” he said.
When Redmond died, he was so unpopular in Ireland that his family decided that his funeral cortege should not move through Dublin’s city centre. Bruton argued, however, that Redmond’s political life had not been a failure, listing legislative achievements that included land reform, the establishment of the National University of Ireland, the introduction of an old age pension and national insurance, and the first ever programme of public housing in Ireland.
“Redmond is a better model for a 21st-century world than are those who did not accept the necessity for compromise, and who failed to make an adequate effort to understand the aspirations of their traditional opponents,” he said.
“When passions are inflamed, absolute demands backed by violence are actually the easy way. No intellectual, or imaginative, effort is required. In these circumstances, compromise is harder, riskier, and more painful. Redmond chose the hard way. He took big political risks, while others sat on their principles – or hid behind them.”