Budget 2019: Who still owes more – the Irish or the Greeks?

Ireland’s national debt is shrinking but don’t splash the cash just yet, we still owe more per head than debt-ridden Greece

 

With Budget 2019 fast approaching, and calls for the Government to push the country’s balance sheet back into the black getting louder, it’s timely to consider just how robust our public finances are. And just how big our national debt is.

On the one hand, significant inroads have been made to reduce our public debt. Having peaked at € 225 billion back in about 2012-2013, it has since fallen to about €189 billion as of the end of August this year.

And when looked at as a percentage of GDP, the metrics look even better. Back in 2013 for example, the national debt accounted for about 119.5 per cent of GDP; it has since fallen substantially, standing at about 69 per cent as of the end of 2017, thanks to strong growth from our multinational sector.

This compares favourably with other indebted countries such as Greece (180 per cent ); France (96 per cent); Italy (131 per cent) ; and Spain (97 per cent).

So what’s the worry then, you might reasonably ask, let’s spend in Budget 2019!

Well, given Ireland’s dependence on foreign multinationals, many economists, including those at the Irish Fiscal Advisory Council, suggest that a more accurate reflection of Ireland’s debt burden is to compare it with the gross national income, or GNI*, as this excludes the impact of multinational companies’ distortions.

When this is used, our debt burden looks a lot heavier, coming in at about 111 per cent for 2017 (down from a peak of 166 per cent in 2012) – so higher then, than both France and Spain.

However, the National Treasury Management Agency (NTMA) does add a caveat with this ratio, warning that “it understates the ability of Ireland to repay debt”, because it excludes sources of tax revenue.

Indeed it argues that while the debt:GDP ratio is too low, the debt:GNI* ratio is “likely too high”. Instead, it argues that “it is fair to say the reality of Ireland’s “proper” debt ratio is somewhere in the middle”.

Debt per person

A clearer way then of looking at our debt, is to consider how much debt, per person, our government would have to pay back to clear the debt. And this calculation is scary enough to make anyone think twice about a “giveaway”budget.

Yes, Ireland has the highest debt per capita of any country in the euro zone. We owe €42,800 per head, more than second-placed Belgium (€40,048) and far more than either Italy (€37,849); Greece (€30,417) or Spain (€25,081). And when you look outside of the euro zone, we’re not too hot either, just lagging the US (€54,000 ) and Japan (€83,000).

Indeed as a recent report from the Department of Finance asserted, “public indebtedness remains high in Ireland, both by historical and international standards”.

If the Government then, is keep the public finances under a tight leash and mitigate the negative impact potential external shocks such as Brexit could have, it will need to improve not just the optics, but the metrics, of Ireland’s public debt predicament.