Netanyahu hits back at Israeli army spokesman who says Hamas cannot be eliminated

Rear Adm Daniel Hagari says Gaza militant group is ‘rooted in the hearts of the people’ and Israel needs a plan to stop it remaining in power

Israeli army spokesman Rear Adm Daniel Hagari: 'To say we are going to make Hamas disappear – it’s simply throwing sand in the eyes of the public.' Photograph: Gil Cohen-Magen/AFP via Getty Images

A senior Israeli military official described the idea of destroying Hamas as “throwing sand in the eyes of the public” as Israel’s leaders feuded over issues ranging from the war in Gaza to the appointment of rabbis.

Rear Adm Daniel Hagari said Hamas would remain in power in Gaza, unless Israel – which has so far failed to agree on a postwar plan for the coastal enclave – came up with an alternative.

“To say we are going to make Hamas disappear – it’s simply throwing sand in the eyes of the public,” the chief spokesman of Israel’s military said in an interview with Israel’s Channel 13 on Wednesday night. “Hamas is an idea, Hamas is a party. It’s rooted in the hearts of the people. Whoever thinks we can eliminate Hamas is wrong.”

Rear Adm Hagari’s comments drew a rebuke from prime minister Binyamin Netanyahu, who issued a statement saying the security cabinet had “defined the destruction of Hamas’s military and governing capabilities as one of the goals of the war”.


“The Israeli military, of course, is committed to this,” the statement added.

Israel and Hizbullah have held back from a full-scale war, but pressure is mountingOpens in new window ]

In response, the military said Rear Adm Hagari had been talking about “the elimination of Hamas as an idea and ideology”, and that any other interpretation was “taking the quote out of context”.

The spat comes amid increasingly public tensions in Israel’s leadership over the course of the war in Gaza, where Israel is far from achieving its objectives of destroying Hamas and freeing the roughly 120 hostages still held by the militant group.

On Sunday, Mr Netanyahu lashed out at the army after it announced a limited pause in operations near a crossing into Gaza that was intended to help aid distribution in the shattered enclave, where aid groups have warned that famine is imminent.

Israeli prime minister Binyamin Netanyahu, defence minister Yoav Gallant and cabinet minister Benny Gantz during a news conference in Tel Aviv, Israel. Photograph: Abir Sultan/AP
The strike follows 33 people being killed at a UN-run school. Photograph: AP

Meanwhile, in recent days, Mr Netanyahu’s son Yair has made a number of posts on social media attacking military leaders.

On Tuesday, he shared a video in which a journalist accused Herzi Halevi, the head of the military, of wanting Hamas to remain in power in Gaza – which the Israel Defense Forces dismissed as a “baseless lie”. A day later he posted a tweet asking where Tomer Bar, the head of Israel’s air force, had been “and what was he doing” during the armed group’s October 7th attack on Israel.

The tensions over Israel’s military strategy have been accompanied by feuding within Mr Netanyahu’s rightwing coalition, with members bickering publicly on Wednesday after a bill on rabbinical appointments was pulled ahead of a vote owing to a lack of support.

That decision prompted fury among Mr Netanyahu’s ultraorthodox coalition partners, with some issuing veiled threats to leave the government. It also sparked a bizarre spat between Mr Netanyahu’s Likud party and the extreme-right Jewish Power party led by Itamar Ben-Gvir, his coalition partner.

Israel-Gaza war: eight Palestinians reported killed as Israeli forces advance deeper into RafahOpens in new window ]

Following reports that Mr Netanyahu had offered Mr Ben-Gvir, who is national security minister, access to security briefings reserved for a limited number of ministers if he supported the bill, Likud said that anyone who wanted access to such information would have to “prove that he is not leaking state secrets or private conversations”.

In response, Jewish Power called for a bill to subject ministers to lie detector tests, “provided that it also applies to those with pacemakers” – in an apparent reference to Mr Netanyahu, who had a pacemaker fitted last year after being hospitalised with heart problems.

People wave Israeli flags during a protest against Israeli prime minister Binyamin Netanyahu’s government. Photograph: Ohad Zwigenberg/AP

There were also signs of tensions within Likud, with economy minister Nir Barkat – widely seen as a future challenger to Mr Netanyahu – saying he would not support the current version of legislation that critics have said would entrench exemptions from military service for the ultraorthodox.

Likud hit back, accusing Barkat of looking for “excuses to topple a rightwing government during wartime”. Meanwhile, Mr Netanyahu issued a statement demanding his coalition partners “get a hold of themselves”.

“We are fighting on several fronts and face great challenges and difficult decisions,” he said. “This is not the time for petty politics or for legislation that endangers the coalition.”

In Gaza, Israeli forces pounded areas in the central coastal strip overnight, killing three people and wounding dozens of others, said medics, while tanks deepened theiri invasion into Rafah in the south, residents have said. – Copyright The Financial Times Limited 2024