The Irish Times view on the biodiversity crisis: nature’s wake-up call

Something fundamental may be shifting in the way we see our relationship with the natural world

‘We need a new economy, with nature at its heart,” Trinity College pollination specialist Jane Stout told some 500 delegates at the biodiversity conference New Horizons for Nature at Dublin Castle last week. Even five years ago, Stout’s view would probably have been regarded as wildly eccentric.

However, the interests represented at the conference ranged from farmers to business people, from Government Ministers to their fiercest critics among veteran environmentalists. It was a remarkable turnout for an event co-organised by a small NGO, the Irish Forum on Natural Capital, and the often-marginalised and always underfunded National Parks and Wildlife Service.

Something fundamental may be shifting in the way we see our relationship with the natural world. We have recently experienced a range of dramatic wake-up calls, from frequent extreme weather events to massive declines in species populations. This sense of cumulative crises was best captured by the President, Michael D Higgins, in a passionate speech. “If we were coal miners,” he said, “we would be up to our knees in dead canaries.” For centuries, our industrial economies have treated nature as a capital resource that can be endlessly exploited, with little reinvestment. But the feedback from ecosystems, as they reach critical tipping points in our century, is telling us that we cannot continue with business as usual.

Our economy, any economy, is ultimately a subset of the environment, not the other way round. And the President was surely right to warn us that our current economic model, based on the illusion of infinite growth and rampant consumerism, is chronically flawed. We need, he said, “to change our mindsets…to achieve a symmetry between ecology, economics and ethics.”


All this, obviously, is much easier said than done. The conference heard a wealth of imaginative perspectives on how to bring about such a transformation. There were many heartening stories of urban and rural communities already engaged in restoring local habitats and ecosystem services. There was robust debate about how to address the climate and biodiversity crises, but general agreement that the two are intimately linked. Many argued that, while economic solutions are now central, we must never lose sight of our deep cultural, aesthetic and even spiritual links to nature.

The conference concluded with the announcement of 40 “Seeds of Nature”, commitments from government departments, agencies and semi-State companies. Most are small steps in the right direction, but fall very far short of what the conference showed is needed, and needed now.

Government and business may at last have heard nature’s wake-up call. But they still need to get out of bed.