UN states concern over Egypt detentions
Human rights chief stops short of saying removal of Morsi constituted a coup d’etat
A man wearing a mask of the ousted Egyptian president Mohammed Morsi stands guard with others outside a rally in the Nasr City neighborhood of Cairo. Photograph: Tara Todras-Whitehill/The New York Times
Protesters with a poster of ousted Egyptian President Mohammed Morsi. Photograph: Tara Todras-Whitehill/The New York Times
Egyptian military jets flew in formation over Tahrir square as the head of Egypt’s constitution court Adli Mansour was sworn in as the interim head of state. Photograph: Mohamed Abd El Ghany/Reuters
United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights Navi Pillay said today she was concerned by reports of the detention of leading members of Egypt’s Muslim Brotherhood, but stopped short of saying whether their overthrow this week constituted a coup d’etat.
“I hope that the rule of law and a system of government that respects the human rights of all Egyptians - men and women - can be quickly re-established,” she said in a statement.
Her spokesman Rupert Colville told a UN briefing that specific crimes would need to have been committed to justify the detentions of the Muslim Brotherhood’s leaders.
“We don’t really know the details and what the basis of these detentions is. Obviously if you detain or arrest someone there needs to be, according to the law, a very good reason to do so,” he said. “There needs to be due process.”
Asked if Egypt’s new rulers should make clear why the figures were being detained or release them, he said: “I think that’s a perfectly reasonable interpretation.”
Ms Pillay said Egypt should seize the chance to become a fully functioning and prosperous democracy, but did not condemn Egypt’s military for overthrowing President Mohamed Mursi, whose policies she had frequently criticised.
“As you know, globally there’s a huge debate going on about whether this was a coup or not a coup or what it is exactly. We’re not getting into that,” Mr Colville said.