Subscriber OnlyPeople

Hugging has become a cultural norm, although it can be a bit performative

I can be picky about who I hug; sometimes there’s a good vibe, other times there can just be ick in the air

Seán Moncrieff: To hug someone – and I mean to really get in there and give them a squeeze – is quite intimate. Photograph: Dara Mac Dónaill/The Irish Times
Seán Moncrieff: To hug someone – and I mean to really get in there and give them a squeeze – is quite intimate. Photograph: Dara Mac Dónaill/The Irish Times

If I meet any men around my own age, and we haven’t seen each other for a while and we are well-disposed to each other, we’ll shake hands. Maybe later, at the end of the night, and after we’ve had a few sweet sherries, we might hug.

To me, this is perfectly natural. To hug someone – and I mean to really get in there and give them a squeeze – is quite intimate, and there is a vast range of situations, and people, for whom it’s not always appropriate. Some people just don’t like it that much.

Unfortunately for them, we are living in the age of hugmaxxing, where the cultural norm, especially among younger people, is to hug all the time. A lot of the time, this isn’t proper hugging. It’s more like air kissing or that dreadful bro backslapping procedure, with both parties getting in and out as quickly as possible as if one of them is about to catch fire.

There’s nothing wrong with any of this of course, even if it can be a bit performative: an exterior action that implies an inner warmth. It’s just that for those who aren’t hug fans, it implies the opposite; that they are cold inside, perhaps detached from their feelings. Perhaps they have no feelings at all. A sociopath will never hug you. Except to stab you in the back.

I know what you’re thinking, and you’re wrong. I love a good hug. I treasure them. And happily, many people in my life feel the same way. Yet I can be picky. Sometimes there’s just a vibe that a hug is definitely coming and it will be welcomed by both people, and other times there can be ick in the air for no identifiable reason. (Actually, sometimes you know exactly why. I’ve met people who within five minutes have declared: ‘I’m a hugger!’ I avoided their huggy overtures for exactly that reason.).

My guess is that most people enjoy a hug but will have their own strictures on where, when and how often hugs should take place. But the hug-everyone-all-the-time culture may have robbed them of any agency in the matter. A German study published last month, which seemed predicated on the assumption that we’re all hugging constantly, asked 15,000 people to recall a hug that was particularly significant to them. Nearly 70 per cent could remember one.

If you can remember that time seven years ago when your auntie hugged you at a junior B hurling match, then you mustn’t get hugged very often. But, according to the authors of the study, that isn’t the reason at all. It’s all to do with “attachment style”. People who maintain a list of their top 10 hugs have an anxious attachment style. They are, perhaps, a little needy. They are keeping score. The remaining 30 per cent who, like me, can’t remember, are apparently “avoidant”: which sounds more than a little judgey.

[ Telling men to open up is not enough – teach them howOpens in new window ]

What the study doesn’t seem to mention is that people who can rate their best hugs, or those who can’t but feel their hugging needs are fulfilled, are lucky. Walk down any street in Ireland, and the chances are you’ll pass someone who hasn’t had physical contact with another human being in weeks or months or even years. Loneliness is an insidious condition that can generate shame and secret bitterness. The lonely often don’t want to admit to their emotional starvation.

And it must be particularly acute for them at this time of the year, when we head into the Christmas buying frenzy, when we must meet up with old friends before the big day, when every media message depicts people settled in the comforting glow of family love. But humans are not so easily predictable. Neither is life. Any of us, through cruel chance, can end up alone. Your best hug is the last one you’ve had.