A journalist behind a programme at the centre of Gerry Adams’s defamation action against the BBC has said she exercised “utmost care and responsibility” in reporting the allegation that the former Sinn Féin leader sanctioned the murder of a British agent.
BBC Spotlight reporter Jennifer O’Leary was giving evidence at the High Court on the third week of a civil trial hearing into Mr Adams’s action.
Mr Adams claims the Spotlight programme and a related article published in 2016 defamed him by falsely accusing him of sanctioning the killing of MI5 agent Denis Donaldson at a cottage in Glenties, Co Donegal in 2006.
The BBC denies it defamed Mr Adams, who insists he had no involvement in the death.
Construction Industry Federation owes €140,000 in derelict levies at €23m site of Dublin 6 terrace collapse
Look inside: Former RTÉ presenter’s Glenageary home with French countryside-style garden for €2.25m
Dr Mike Ryan is dropped from WHO executive team amid ‘painful’ cost cuts
How to set boundaries in your personal and work relationships, and why it’s important
On Wednesday, under cross-examination by Tom Hogan SC, for Mr Adams, Ms O’Leary said the “serious” allegation, made against Mr Adams by an anonymous contributor to the programme dubbed “Martin”, was treated with the “utmost care and responsibility”.
She said she made efforts to meet as many credible sources as possible in carrying out her investigation. “I had over 60 meetings after the interview with Martin was recorded,” she said.
Ms O’Leary had previously told the court that Martin’s claims were corroborated by two republican and three security services sources.
Ms O’Leary said that in meetings with members of An Garda Síochána during her reporting, it was made “explicitly clear” to her that the force’s investigation of Mr Donaldson‘s murder was focused on “who pulled the trigger”, not who might have directed the murder.
Asked why she did not ask Garda sources about the allegation that Mr Adams sanctioned the Donaldson killing, she said it was a sensitive and serious allegation, and she was being careful and fair to Mr Adams.
“[The Garda sources] made it explicitly clear that they had a different focus. They were looking at the trigger men ... that’s not the allegation that we made about Gerry Adams in the programme,” she said.
Ms O’Leary agreed that she was aware of Antoin Duffy, who Mr Hogan described as a dissident republican, and the prime suspect in Mr Donaldson’s killing. Ms O’Leary said she’d “made it her business” to be aware of who was the focus of the Garda investigation.
Ms O’Leary said she did not put Mr Duffy’s name explicitly to Martin – or the other five sources who she said corroborated his allegations – in her questioning about Mr Donaldson’s killing. She said she put to her sources the Real IRA’s claim of responsibility for Mr Donaldson’s death in 2009.
Ms O’Leary said she disagreed with Mr Hogan’s suggestion that in the programme, Martin states as a matter of fact that IRA murders have to be approved by its political and military leadership, and “Gerry Adams, he gives the final say” [on the decision].
Ms O’Leary said Martin’s words are presented “in the context of an allegation”. She said “any reasonable person” watching the programme would know “we are making an allegation”.
Mr Hogan put it to Ms O’Leary that the word “sanction” was used only by her in the programme, and not Martin. The word is used in the programme – and related article – in outlining the allegation made against Mr Adams.
Ms O’Leary said she didn’t dispute Mr Hogan’s assertion, but said Martin had used the word in outlining the allegation against Mr Adams when they met in February 2016.
Ms O’Leary’s cross-examination, and the trial, continues.
