TDs call for class actions in tracker mortgage scandal

Culture won’t change until banks are prosecuted, committee hears

The banking culture which led to the current tracker mortgage scandal will not change until the banks are pursued through the courts, the Oireachtas finance committee heard yesterday.

Chairman John McGuinness, of Fianna Fáil, and Sinn Féin's Pearse Doherty called on Minister for Finance Paschal Donohoe, who was appearing before the committee, to support class-action legislation, which would allow victims of widespread harm to come together in search of collective redress.

Mr Doherty said banks were “getting away with the biggest theft in the history of the State” with almost €1 billion wrongly denied to low-cost tracker mortgage-holders and yet the legislation had not provided them with an efficient route to legal redress.


If the same scenario was played out in Iceland, Mr Doherty said, the banks would face criminal prosecution for theft. “If it was in America you would have bankers walked out of their institutions with handcuffs,” he added.


Mr Doherty said his party had drafted class-action legislation on foot of recommendations from the Law Reform Commission.

Echoing Mr Doherty’s comments, Mr McGuinness said that until such class-action cases were taken against individual banks, they were unlikely to clean up their acts or change their culture.


Mr Donohoe stopped short of saying his party would support class-action legislation, noting he had not considered it and that it was not specific to financial services, but he indicated he would support beefing up Central Bank’s regulatory powers.

"My current view is that the legal framework is in place to deal with this matter and the test of that will be work that the Central Bank can do," he said.

The Central Bank’s trawl into affected customers has uncovered more than 33,700 cases where the banks either denied customers their right to a low-cost mortgage linked to the ECB’s main lending rate or applied the incorrect rate.

Earlier, he acknowledged there were currently no public interest directors on the boards of any of the State-owned banks.

Eoin Burke-Kennedy

Eoin Burke-Kennedy

Eoin Burke-Kennedy is Economics Correspondent of The Irish Times