Electricity grids designed so generators switch off when system loses synchronisation, expert explains

Detailed study required before coming to definitive view on what happened in Spain and Portugal on Monday, says UCC professor

A public bus in Barcelona pictured at night during a massive power cut affecting the entire Iberian peninsula and the south of France, on Monday. Photograph: Josep Lago/AFP via Getty Images
A public bus in Barcelona pictured at night during a massive power cut affecting the entire Iberian peninsula and the south of France, on Monday. Photograph: Josep Lago/AFP via Getty Images

Data on the cause or causes of the complete blackout of the electricity grids in both Portugal and Spain on Tuesday will be examined by experts and provide valuable “learnings” for grid operators around the world, according to one Irish expert.

Barry Hayes, associate professor in electrical power systems at University College Cork, said credence had to be given to the explanation offered by the operator of the Portuguese grid as to why the outage had happened, but it was best to avoid speculation until a definitive view was provided.

The operator of the Portuguese power grid, REN, said power supply interruptions in Portugal were due to a fault in the Spanish electricity grid.

Extreme temperature variations in the interior of Spain had caused anomalous oscillations in the very high voltage lines, it said, causing a phenomenon known as “induced atmospheric vibration”.

READ MORE

The oscillations caused synchronisation failures between the electrical systems, REN said, leading to successive disturbances across the European network.

However, later in the day the Spanish prime minister, Pedro Sánchez, said they did not yet have conclusive information as to the reasons for the power cut.

Electricity grids, Hayes said, have been described as the largest machine ever built by mankind, with millions of components that all need to work together.

Power outage update: Spain declares state of emergency; Portugal grid operator says issue caused by rare phenomenonOpens in new window ]

The major power generators linked to the grid have to run within a certain tight frequency band and are all synchronised with each other.

“As soon as you go outside that frequency range all of the generators are programmed to disconnect instantly because you can cause a lot of damage to the generators and surrounding grid,” he said.

“That’s what happened at 11.30 today: all of the large generators in Portugal and Spain just disconnected.”

As far as he could make out, there had not been any particularly high temperatures in Spain or Portugal on Monday, he noted.

Getting the grids back up and running requires a “black start” where one generator is started up, and then another, all synchronising with the local grid, and progressing across the country until the whole grid is operating again, he said.

What happened in Spain and Portugal was one of the largest, if not the largest, electricity blackouts ever in Europe, Hayes said.

The blackout will have left a huge amount of data in its wake, along with other evidence, that can be pored over in the coming period for why Iberia lost its power on Monday. The evidence is likely to provide “huge learnings” that will be of interest to experts around the globe and help the effort to minimise the risk of such outages in the future, the academic said.

Colm Keena

Colm Keena

Colm Keena is an Irish Times journalist. He was previously legal-affairs correspondent and public-affairs correspondent