Another year, another overspend as health needs almost €800m more

Overall Government spending this year will be close to €120 billion. It is hard to fathom

Budget 2007
HSE chief Anne O’Connor is expected to tell the Oireachtas committee today that the health service faces a 'very serious financial position'

Cost overruns in Government departmental spending seem less like a news story and more like an annual occurrence, a predictable repeating pattern.

Martin Wall and Cormac McQuinn report that supplementary estimates will be required in a number of departments and public bodies to address €1.7 billion of overspending this year.

The biggest culprit, as it is every year, is the health service, which will receive almost €800 million extra for 2026.

It means that overall spending this year will be close to €120 billion.

It is hard to fathom. That’s an 80 per cent increase in Government spending in 2026 compared with only seven years ago in 2019, when it was less than €70 billion.

Health, in particular, has risen steeply.

As we report, spending has increased by 88 per cent, or €13.7 billion, since 2019, from €15.7 billion to almost €30 billion. The figures are staggering.

Such bailouts happen every year. In November 2023, a supplementary health budget of €960 million was agreed, and in October 2024, then finance minister Paschal Donohoe agreed a supplementary health estimate of €1.75 billion.

What the Cabinet agreed yesterday is less than the €1 billion shortfall anticipated in recent weeks, but that is a small mercy.

HSE chief executive Anne O’Connor is expected to tell the Oireachtas committee today that the health service faces a “very serious financial position”.

No information has been given on the other errant departments that have broken their budgets this year.

Oireachtas locked in battle over triple lock

The Opposition’s attempt to block the Government’s efforts to dismantle the triple lock will probably be the biggest co-ordinated campaign mounted during the Coalition’s term of office, as we report today.

It is unusual that parties of all hues on the Opposition benches object to a piece of legislation. It will be marked by the use of a full array of parliamentary devices to oppose the Bill within Leinster House and a public campaign with demonstrations, marches and rallies. The first big event will take place on Saturday in Dublin.

As happened last week, the exchanges between Taoiseach Micheál Martin and Sinn Féin leader Mary Lou McDonald in the Dáil yesterday were pointed and bitter, with accusations of false narratives and untruths.

However, for the Opposition to have any hope of defeating the Defence (Amendment) Bill it will have to recruit a number of defectors from Fianna Fáil, some of whose backbench TDs feel very uneasy with the legislation. They argue that removing the triple lock, and the UN mandate, flies in the face of the party’s traditional position on this issue.

The issue was thrashed out at the Fianna Fáil parliamentary party last night with veteran TD Willie O’Dea, a former minister for defence, leading the charge.

As we report, O’Dea will submit an amendment this morning to the Oireachtas Committee on Defence and National Security, seeking the insertion of extra conditions to the deployment of Irish troops overseas. While it will not seek to restore the requirement of United Nations Security Council approval, the amendment will seek to attach some level of UN approval, perhaps even a vote on an issue by the General Assembly.

The triple lock requires UN approval – from the US, UK, France, Russia and China – as well as Oireachtas and Government support before 12 or more members of the Defence Forces can be sent overseas with an armed international force or body.

O’Dea wants deployments of Irish troops to be predicated on a current resolution of the UN General Assembly and that a minister seeking to send troops overseas would have to make a statement explaining how the deployment would be consistent with the aims and purposes of that resolution.

The UN would not have to mandate the mission concerned, according to the amendment, which states: “It shall be sufficient that the dispatch of the contingent concerned is wholly consistent with the aims and purposes of the relevant general assembly resolution.”

However, as we report, Fine Gael is not too keen on that amendment.

The amendment will be submitted by O’Dea this morning to the defence committee, as well as an expected 100 or more other submissions, mainly by Opposition TDs. The committee stage of the Bill is expected to be drawn out and may ultimately be guillotined by the Government, which wants it passed by the end of the year.

Best Reads

Sarah Burns reports that Sinn Féin has a new policy document on gender identity. It was met with mixed responses from other Opposition parties.

Cassandra corner. Michael McDowell in his column writes that Ireland is paddling its economic canoe towards Niagara Falls.

Niamh Towey reports that RTÉ chairman Terence O’Rourke wrote to Minister for Culture Patrick O’Donovan accusing the Government of backtracking in the budget on its funding commitments to the broadcaster.

Playbook

Highlights

Labour’s motion on the health budget and recruitment will focus on funding in Cork University Hospital. The Media Regulation Bill and the Short-Term Letting Bill are nearing the end of their passage through the Oireachtas.

The Health Committee will examine budgetary and staffing challenges within the HSE.

Dáil Éireann

9.00am: Topical issues.

10.00am: Private members’ business (Labour Party): Motion on health budget and recruitment restrictions.

12.00pm: Leaders’ Questions (Sinn Féin, Social Democrats, Labour Party, Independent and Parties Technical Group).

12.34pm: Other Members’ Questions.

12.42pm: Questions on policy or legislation.

1.12pm: Bills for introduction:

Property Services (Regulation) (Amendment) Bill 2026 – First stage

Data Centre Transparency Bill 2026 – First stage

Electricity Regulation (Amendment) (Hardship Meters) Bill 2026 – First stage

2.27pm: Government Business: Statements on childcare.

5.59pm: Government Business: Media Regulation Bill 2026 – Amendments from the Seanad.

6.59pm: Government Business: Motion on proposed approval by Dáil Éireann of the Horse and Greyhound Racing Fund Regulations 2026.

7.59pm: Government Business: Motion on proposed approval of a regulation concerning the European Union Agency for Criminal Justice Cooperation (Eurojust), repealing regulation (EU) 2018/1727.

8.59pm: Deferred Divisions.

Seanad Éireann

10.30am: Commencement Matters.

11.30am: Order of Business.

1.00pm: Government Business: Broadcasting (Amendment) Bill 2026 – Committee stage.

3.00pm: Government Business: Short-Term Letting and Tourism Bill 2026 – Committee and remaining stages.

5.00pm: Private Members’ Business: Motion regarding community policing.

Committee Meetings

9.30am: Joint Committee on Transport – Engagement with Local Link network.

9.30am: Joint Committee on Social Protection, Rural and Community Development – Citizens Information Board: Engagement with chair-designate Claire Byrne.

9.30am: Joint Committee on Disability Matters – Participation in social and cultural life.

9.30am: Joint Committee on Health – Challenges relating to budgetary and staffing matters in the HSE.

10.45am: Select Committee on Social Protection, Rural and Community Development – Committee Stage consideration of the Social Welfare, Civil Registration and Charities (Amendment) Bill 2026.

12.30pm: Select Committee on Enterprise, Tourism and Employment – 2025 Supplementary Estimates for Public Services: Vote 32 – Enterprise, Tourism and Employment.

12.30pm: Joint Committee on Education and Youth – Educational needs of students with English as an additional language.

12.30pm: Joint Committee on Arts, Media, Communications, Culture and Sport – Inclusion in sport.

12.30pm: Joint Committee on Climate, Environment and Energy – Update from NEAT.

3.30pm: Joint Committee on Agriculture and Food – Emergency crop loss support.

3.30pm: Joint Committee on Infrastructure and National Development Plan Delivery – Engagement on progress under the NDP sectoral plan: justice sector.

3.30pm: Joint Committee on Finance, Public Expenditure, Public Service Reform and Digitalisation, and Taoiseach – Climate financing.

News Digests

News Digests

Stay on top of the latest news with our daily newsletters each morning, lunchtime and evening