Subscriber OnlyLetters

The stain of original sin is not what many people think it is

It is an absence of something

Letters to the Editor. Illustration: Paul Scott
The Irish Times - Letters to the Editor.

Sir, – Here is a response to the weekend interview with Mary McAleese in which she expressed “real difficulty with the concept of original sin” (“I’m not going to argue with God, but Canon Law is man-made,” November 14th):

One of the difficulties with the doctrine of original sin is with the way original sin is described as a stain. When people hear about that, it gives the impression that original sin is like a dirty mark on a newborn baby that needs to be scrubbed off and washed away with the waters of Baptism. Understandably, people find this image difficult to accept because it seems to deny the beauty, goodness and sacredness of new life.

But this is a misunderstanding of what the church teaches about original sin. The church does not teach that the stain of original sin is something within us or on us, but rather that it is an absence of something, a loss of something, an emptiness within us. The church actually defines original sin as a deprivation of the grace of original holiness and justice (Catechism 404, 405, 417).

In other words, we enter this world not with a dirty mark on us, not with the need to have something removed from us, but rather we enter this world as empty vessels waiting and needing to be filled with the grace and the love of God.

Connected to the doctrine of original sin, the church believes that, in her immaculate conception, Mary was conceived without the stain of original sin, without that emptiness within her. To put it another way, Mary was conceived, “full of grace” (Luke 1:28). Through the grace of the sacraments, beginning with the sacrament of Baptism, we are also filled with grace.

In this sense, Our Blessed Lady is not so different and far removed from us, but rather Mary is the example of what God can, and hopefully will, achieve in each of us. Just as Mary was conceived immaculate, so also, God willing, we will be made immaculate.

And just as Mary was assumed body and soul into heaven, so also, God willing, we will one day join her body and soul in the everlasting joy of heaven.- Yours, etc,

FR ANTONY JUKES,

Franciscan Friary,

Killarney

Co Kerry.