Israeli death penalty advocates win preliminary vote

The vote was denounced as ‘an expression of the state of confusion’ in Israel’s policies

The motion was brought by defence minister Avigdor Lieberman, who advocates tough action against Palestinian militants. Photograph: Getty

Israel’s parliament gave preliminary approval on Wednesday for legislation that would make it easier to impose a death sentence on assailants convicted of murder in attacks classified as terrorism.

Israeli military courts, which handle cases involving Palestinians in the occupied West Bank, already have the power to issue the death sentence but this has never been implemented. The only case of an execution in Israel was carried out against convicted Nazi war criminal Adolf Eichmann in 1962.

The amendment to the penal code would still require three more readings if it is to become law.

Currently, a death penalty can only be imposed if a panel of three military judges passes sentence unanimously. If the amendment is adopted, a majority verdict would suffice.


The motion was brought by defence minister Avigdor Lieberman, an ultra-nationalist in the conservative coalition government, who advocates tough action against Palestinian militants. Fifty-two of parliament’s 120 members voted in favour and 49 were opposed.

Qadura Fares, chairman of the Palestinian Prisoner Club which represents Palestinians jailed in Israel, denounced the vote as “an expression of the state of blindness and confusion in the policies of this fascist regime (where) extremist parties race to pass racist laws.

“While the world moves toward repealing the death penalty, Israel is working to ratify this law, which is directed against the Palestinians,” Fares told Reuters.

Israeli prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu voted for the motion but said such legislation required deeper discussion. He added the matter would now be considered at ministerial level before further debate in the Knesset.

In remarks to lawmakers, he said: “I think that in extreme cases, when somebody slaughters and laughs (as he kills), he should not spend the rest of his time in jail and should be executed.”

When asked by an Israeli Arab lawmaker whether he would apply this reasoning to Jewish militants convicted of killing Palestinians, Netanyahu said: “In principle, yes.”

The successful vote was the latest in a number of motions brought by right-wing coalition members who feel able to pressure Netanyahu’s brittle government into enacting hard-line legislation. – Reuters