EU split grows and rules fray as migrant crisis intensifies

Germany calls for unity as central European states seek their own tough stance

The European Union’s border and asylum policies were in disarray on Monday night, as member states sought their own solutions to a continuing surge in migrants from the Middle East, Africa and south Asia.

On Monday, Hungary lifted a ban on migrants using international trains, amid outrage over last week's death of 71 people in a truck driven by suspected people smugglers, only for Austrian border police to stop migrant-filled trains from Budapest to Germany for several hours.

Austrian police said they wanted to check migrants' papers and send those who had applied for asylum in Hungary back to Budapest. But when the trains finally entered Austria, it seemed the police had abandoned their plan.

Traffic jam

At the same time, at a border crossing on the main Vienna- Budapest motorway, a traffic jam grew to some 30km as Austrian authorities searched vans and trucks for migrants being taken over the frontier illegally.


The move was part of a major crackdown on people smugglers across Hungary, Austria and Germany, but made of a mockery of the “borderless” and “passport-free” travel promised in the EU’s so-called Schengen zone of 26 states.

Hungary's unexpected decision to allow people without EU visas to leave on international trains appeared to be a breach of its obligations under the Schengen agreement, and an admission that a controversial razor-wire fence it has unfurled along its border with Serbia has done nothing to slow the arrival of migrants.

‘Special trains’

The German government denied that “special trains” were bringing migrants from Budapest, and insisted Hungary register all migrants arriving there. Officials in Budapest, meanwhile, asked Berlin to clarify its position on how illegal migrants could travel around the EU.

"Europe as a whole must move. Member states must share responsibility for asylum-seeking refugees," German chancellor Angela Merkel said. "If we don't arrive at a fair distribution then the issue of Schengen will arise – we do not want that."

As Germany prepares to accept some 800,000 asylum- seekers this year, however, Hungary and other central European states have derided proposals to distribute refugees around the bloc on a quota system – opening a rift in the EU over how to handle a crisis that shows no sign of abating.

Hungary's foreign ministry summoned France's envoy to Budapest, after Paris's foreign minister Laurent Fabius said eastern European states and Hungary in particular were showing a "scandalous" attitude towards asylum-seekers.

“They are extremely harsh. Hungary is part of Europe, which has values, and we do not respect those value by putting up fences,” Mr Fabius said.

“Hungary is not respecting Europe’s common values so the European authorities need to have a serious discussion, even a stern discussion, with its officials.”

Ahead of an emergency meeting of EU justice and interior ministers to discuss migration that is due to take place in a fortnight, Hungary and its central European neighbours look set to forge their own, tough position this week.

"We strongly reject any quotas," Slovak prime minister Robert Fico said on Monday, as he and Czech premier Bohuslav Sobotka invited their Hungarian and Polish counterparts to meet on Friday in Prague.


“If a mechanism for automatic redistribution of migrants is adopted, then we will wake up one day and have 100,000 people from the Arab world and that is a problem I would not like


to have,” Mr Fico said.

“We are prepared to do what is needed and what is within our possibilities, for people who really need help [and] separate them from economic migrants,” he added.

As well as opposing quotas, central European leaders have suggested Muslim refugees could spread Islamic extremism and terror in the region, and expressed a preference for Christian over Muslim refugees, while also insisting that they need to prepare for a possible influx of people fleeing Ukraine’s conflict.

"Some people suppose that the migration wave is a short- term phenomenon and it will stop. In my opinion, it will grow stronger," Czech president Milos Zeman said.

"Of course I would want the EU to strengthen its borders, but I don't see any real action . . . Therefore I believe the Czech Republic should take care of its borders alone and expel illegal immigrants . . . including with use of the army."

Daniel McLaughlin

Daniel McLaughlin

Daniel McLaughlin is a contributor to The Irish Times from central and eastern Europe