New Zealand election tally strengthens Labour in negotiations

Prime minister says final count will not affect talks, which are likely to focus on economy

Jacinda Ardern (centre), New Zealand’s new opposition Labour leader, speaks to the press alongside members of her party in August. Photograph: Charlotte Greenfield/Reuters/File Photo

Jacinda Ardern (centre), New Zealand’s new opposition Labour leader, speaks to the press alongside members of her party in August. Photograph: Charlotte Greenfield/Reuters/File Photo


A possible Labour-Green coalition narrowed the gap with the ruling National Party in New Zealand’s final election tally, strengthening their position ahead of talks on Sunday with the small nationalist party which holds the balance of power.

The final September 23rd election results released on Saturday showed National won 56 seats and Labour and Greens together took 54 seats, leaving them both reliant on New Zealand First’s nine seats to meet the 61 seats needed for a majority in parliament in New Zealand’s proportional representation system.

National lost two seats to the Labour-Green bloc compared with preliminary results - a development which Labour leader Jacinda Ardern said buoyed their position at the negotiating table.

“We will continue our negotiations in earnest with potential support parties beginning this weekend,” Ms Ardern told reporters in Auckland.

“This now means that we have a strengthened mandate to negotiate and form a durable, stable coalition government.”

Ardern (37) took over the Labour leadership nearly two months before the election, quickly drawing comparisons with youthful, cosmopolitan leaders like Canada’s Justin Trudeau and France’s Emmanuel Macron. She has almost single-handedly brought Labour to within reach of forming government.

New Zealand First said in an emailed statement that it would hold discussions on Sunday with the National Party at midday and with the Labour Party in the afternoon.

New Zealand First leader Winston Peters told local media that knowing the facts “puts us in a better position to make judgements”.

Mr Peters has said he would only make a decision on which party to back after the final tally and after the results become official on October 12th.

Prime minister Bill English told reporters in Queenstown that the final results did not change the nature of the negotiations, which would now likely focus on the economy.

“I don’t think it weakens it significantly at all,” he said, referring to National’s negotiating position. “The fundamentals haven’t altered, and that is National has significantly more seats than Labour, we are larger than a Labour-Greens combination.”

Gain in seats

If New Zealand First chooses to go with Labour, which are thought to have more in common in terms of policy, the gain in seats for the Labour-Greens bloc would make it easier for Mr Peters to justify the move, analysts said.

Both parties have said they want to curb immigration, renegotiate certain trade deals and adjust the role of the central bank albeit in different ways.

“If Labour, the Greens and NZ First had formed a government with a majority of one (seat)...that wouldn’t have sat comfortably with many people,” Richard Shaw, politics professor at Massey University, refering to preliminary results.

A Labour, Greens, NZ First coalition would now hold a three-seat majority after the final tally.

But some say Mr Peters could be swayed to go to National given it would be a straightforward coalition between two parties.

Mr Peters, a veteran New Zealand politician who has now held the balance of power three times, has in past elections formed coalition governments with both the National Party and Labour.

The National Party won 44.4 per cent of the votes, the Labour Party 36.9 per cent, New Zealand First 7.2 per cent, the Green Party 6.3 per cent.