Report highlights 'scarring' effect of homelessness on children

Majority of families interviewed ‘deeply negatively affected by becoming homeless’

The CEO of Inner City Helping Homeless Anthony Flynn, has called for the director of Dublin’s Regional Homeless Executive to, “consider her position”, in the wake of comments made regarding “ad hoc” unauthorised groups supporting homeless services.

 

The long-term, negative impact of homelessness on children, particularly older children, is set out in a ground-breaking report published on Saturday.

Commissioned by Focus Ireland, the report says families placed in social housing after homelessness recover more quickly than those placed in the private rented sector, as the latter remained anxious about becoming homeless again.

Researchers Brian Harvey and Dr Kathy Walsh conducted in-depth interviews with 25 families who had exited homelessness between March 2014 and September 2016 for the report, Finding a Home: Families Journeys Out of Homelessness. It is the first such research conducted in Ireland.

“The vast majority of the families interviewed reported being deeply negatively affected by becoming homeless,” say the authors. Impacts included damage to physical and mental health, relationship breakdown, job loss, behavioural problems among children and adverse impact on children’s education.

Homelessness was “a time of considerable stress, intensive at first then of less intensity but prolonged and just as potentially scarring... Personal relationships and family discipline generally deteriorated.”

Kitchen area in a Dublin homeless shelter. Researchers who interviewed 25 families who exited homelessness between March 2014 and September 2016 say impacts included damage to physical and mental health and job loss. Photograph: Alan Betson
Kitchen area in a Dublin homeless shelter.  Photograph: Alan Betson

Among the biggest challenges for children were lack of certainty, lack of play space, overcrowding, boredom and reduced socialisation.

“Our son’s behaviour went out of control. There was nothing for him to do,” said one parent. Another commented: “ My daughter’s behaviour changed. She fought with me and her dad, which was unheard of. She cried a lot and acted out.”

For very young children the impact appeared, said the parents, to be not as long-term. “For older children the impact was greater and more visible.”

In many cases “some of the issues related to being homeless only emerged for older children following the move out of homeless accommodation”.

One parent said: “Our 14 year-old didn’t do well in school [when homeless]. He didn’t study. There was no place quiet for him to study and he was too tired from all the travelling we had to do to get to school... Things are starting to improve but he has lost the good studying habits he used to have.”

The more resilient and resourceful families were better equipped to exit homelessness. Finding a home “greatly tested the social skill and personal resilience of each of the families interviewed”.

The most recent Department of Housing figures show there were 1,455 families, including 3,124 children, in emergency accommodation in September. So far this year Focus Ireland has assisted more than 300 families in exiting homelessness.