Open season on Rubio at GOP debate in New Hampshire
Republican candidate on receiving end of Christie’s strong performance during debate
Republican presidential candidate Donald Trump (left) confers with fellow candidate Marco Rubio(right) during a break in the Republican presidential candidates debate on Saturday at St Anselm’s College Institute of Politics in Manchester, New Hampshire. Photograph: Getty
Republican US presidential candidates (from left to right) governor John Kasich, former governor Jeb Bush, senator Marco Rubio, businessman Donald Trump, senator Ted Cruz, Dr Ben Carson and governor Chris Christie at the Republican US presidential candidates debate sponsored by ABC News on Saturday. Photograph: Reuters
Screens showing republican US presidential candidate businessman Donald Trump (right) and former governor Jeb Bush (left) debate as US senator Marco Rubio (centre) stands between the two men. Photograph: Reuters
Republican contender Marco Rubio struggled at a presidential debate on Saturday at the worst possible time, potentially confounding his bid to emerge as Donald Trump’s chief rival in New Hampshire and giving hope to three rivals desperate for a strong showing.
Under assault from New Jersey governor Chris Christie over his level of experience as a first-term US senator from Florida, Mr Rubio retreated time and again to canned statements from his stump speech and looked uncomfortably rattled for the first time after seamless performances at seven prior debates.
“Marco, the thing is this,” Mr Christie said during one heated exchange early in the night, “when you’re president of the United States, when you’re a governor of a state, the memorized 30-second speech where you talk about how great America is at the end of it doesn’t solve one problem for one person.”
While Mr Rubio recovered later in the debate, the timing of his performance was terrible, coming three days before New Hampshire Republicans register their choices on Tuesday in the nation’s second nominating contest.
The debate at St Anselm College was the last face-off of the candidates before the vote.
Mr Rubio’s tough moments may breathe new life into the campaigns of Mr Christie, former Florida governor Jeb Bush and Ohio governor John Kasich, three experienced politicians who, like Mr Rubio, represent establishment Republicans.
All three have suffered from the dominance of front-runner Mr Trump in the Republican race. They are badly in need of a breakout moment to change the trajectory of the battle in New Hampshire, where the polls show Mr Trump in the lead, Mr Rubio in second and Texas Senator Ted Cruz in third place.
Mr Trump did not have his best debate. He looked flustered in a fight with Mr Bush over the use of eminent domain in advancing the interests of public use projects and private industry.
But he seemed to do well enough to possibly win on Tuesday in what would represent his first victory of the 2016 race, erasing the pain from a loss in the Iowa caucus last week, where he finished second to Mr Cruz and just ahead of the surging Mr Rubio.
A victory in New Hampshire could put Mr Trump on track for more wins in South Carolina on February 20th and beyond on the way to the November 8th election.
For the second debate in a row, Mr Bush looked polished and sounded like the candidate many establishment Republicans had pinned their hopes on. His problem is it may be too late.
Mr Kasich, likely to end his candidacy if he does not do well on Tuesday, delivered a positive message that could appeal to New Hampshire Republican voters, who famously make up their minds late and never seem in the mood to follow the lead of the Iowa caucuses, won by Mr Cruz.
The trouble for Mr Rubio began soon after the debate started when the ABC News moderators asked Mr Christie about Mr Rubio’s experience in the US Senate, and Christie pressed his case.
Mr Rubio critics have made much of the fact that his experience is akin to that of much-derided Democratic president Barack Obama, elected in 2008 when a first-term senator.
Mr Rubio’s defense was that his and Obama’s world views are different, not that Mr Obama has simply led the country down the path it is on because of inexperience.
“Let’s dispel with this fiction that Barack Obama doesn’t know what he’s doing. He knows exactly what he’s doing,” Mr Rubio said.
When Mr Rubio repeated the same line again, Mr Christie sought to reinforce the charge that Mr Rubio is so inexperienced that he relies on well-worn talking points and cannot think on his feet.
“There it is. There it is. The memorized 25-second speech. There it is, everybody,” Mr Christie said.
Mr Rubio repeated the line enough that someone created a Twitter profile called @RubioGlitch that repeated his line about Mr Obama.
Mr Bush attacked Mr Trump for using ‘eminent domain’, which allows governments to seize private lands for projects for the public good, to help him build casino complexes in Atlantic City.
Eminent domain is a frequent target of criticism from conservative and anti-government groups.
“What Donald Trump did was use eminent domain to try to take the property of an elderly woman on the strip in Atlantic City. That is not public purpose. That is downright wrong,” he said.
Mr Trump said eminent domain was “a good thing” and was necessary to building roads, bridges, schools and hospitals. “Certainly, it’s a necessity for our country,” he said.
“He wants to be a tough guy, and it doesn’t work very well,” Mr Trump said of Mr Bush, telling the son and brother of former presidents to be quiet.
When the crowd booed, Mr Trump said, “that’s all his donors and special interests out there.”
Mr Trump, known for his tough stances with calls to ban Muslims from visiting the United States and deport immigrants without the proper documents, also called for a more empathetic view of the Republican call to repeal Obamacare insurance coverage for Americans.
“There will be a certain number of people who will be on the street dying, and as a Republican I don’t want that to happen,” he said.
Mr Trump captured the biggest share of the conversation on Twitter during the debate, winning 33 per cent of the conversation followed by Rubio at 20 per cent and Cruz at 15 per cent.