Iran nuclear talks reach impasse on details
Negotiations continue but deal on lifting of UN sanctions among key outstanding issues
Searching for a deal .... US secretary of state John Kerry looks at the view of Lake Geneva from his hotel room as the Iran nuclear talks continue, in Lausanne, Switzerland, on Wednesday. Photograph: Laurent Gillieron/EPA
Major powers and Iran were closer to a preliminary accord on reining in Tehran’s nuclear programme as marathon talks ran into Wednesday, but they hit an impasse over key details such as the lifting of UN sanctions and Iran’s future atomic research.
The negotiators ended talks in the Swiss city of Lausanne in the early morning hours with an air of chaos, disunity and cacophony as delegations scrambled to get contradictory viewpoints across.
The six powers – the United States, Britain, France, Germany, Russia and China – aim to stop Iran from gaining the capacity to develop a nuclear bomb in exchange for easing international sanctions that are crippling its economy. Iran says its nuclear programme is peaceful.
France’s foreign minister Laurent Fabius, often seen as making the most stringent demands of Iran, returned to Paris because things had not advanced enough for an “immediate deal”.
But as top negotiators from the powers met Iran’s foreign minister Mohammad Javad Zarif again on Wednesday, Russia and Iran expressed optimism that an initial agreement was within reach.
Britain’s foreign secretary Philip Hammond sounded a note of caution. “I think we have a broad framework of understanding, but there are still some key issues that have to be worked through,” he told the BBC.
Western diplomats said Iran had on Tuesday reaffirmed its “nuclear rights”, suggesting the talks were again getting bogged down as they entered their seventh day.
Officials cautioned that any agreement would probably be fragile and incomplete.
“We hope to wrap up the talks by Wednesday night ... We insist on lifting of financial, oil and banking sanctions immediately ... for other sanctions we need to find a framework,” senior Iranian negotiator Abbas Araqchi told state television. “We insist on keeping research and development with advanced centrifuges,” he said.
Mr Zarif said the talks had been “very good”, though he acknowledged that there were issues to be smoothed over.
A preliminary deal would be a major milestone toward a final accord, with an end-June deadline, that could end a 12-year standoff between Iran and world powers and reduce the risk of another Middle East war.
The United States threatened on Tuesday to walk away if the current talks yielded no political framework accord.
The talks have stalled on the issues of Iran’s nuclear centrifuge research, the lifting of UN sanctions and their restoration if Iran breaches the agreement.
But a diplomat close to the talks denied that such an agreement had been reached, and Mr Fabius left saying he would only return if it was “necessary”.
“Things have progressed, but not enough ... that we can reach an immediate deal,” France’s foreign minister told reporters in Paris. “We are firm. We want a robust deal with detailed checks.”
China warned of failure and urged all sides to meet each other half way. “If the talks are stuck then all previous efforts to resolve Iran’s nuclear standoff with the six major powers will have been wasted,” said the rare statement issued by the Chinese delegation after foreign minister Wang Yi left Lausanne.
The US administration of President Barack Obama had committed to meeting an end-March deadline for the outline political accord.
Negotiators have a tentative agreement on the rough outline of a possible public statement on the progress they have made so far that would also highlight areas of disagreement, diplomats close to the talks said. But they have not agreed on all the key details central to a political framework that would form the basis of a future nuclear agreement, the diplomats said.
Some parts of any understanding reached by the parties will likely remain confidential.
Failure to agree a detailed preliminary accord would add to scepticism in the Republican-controlled US Congress over an emerging deal. Congress has warned it will consider imposing new sanctions on Iran if there is no agreement this week. Mr Obama has threatened to veto any such sanctions moves.
Mr Lavrov said the possible agreement included the International Atomic Energy Agency’s monitoring of Iran’s nuclear programme as well as steps to lift sanctions. Experts would work out technical details by the end of June.
“One can say with enough confidence that ministers have reached a general agreement on all key aspects of a final settlement to this issue,” Mr Lavrov said. “It will be put down in writing over the next few hours, maybe during the day.”
A senior Iranian negotiator said Tehran was willing to negotiate until the deadlock was resolved. “Iran does not want a nuclear deal just for the sake of having a deal, and a final deal should guarantee the Iranian nation’s nuclear rights,” the negotiator, Hamid Baidinejad, told reporters.