The quotes and chronology that led to Mr Smith's apology.
November 11th:
"I call on every member of this house to concentrate on what the Hanly report actually says and on its real implication. Let's deal with facts, not fear." - Minister for Health, Mr Martin, during a Dáil debate.
"This is a report, and there is quite a considerable aspect and time lag in term of its implementation. I will be watching every line of it and nobody is going to take me for granted anywhere." - Minister for Defence Mr Smith.
"Minister Smith stated that he refused to endorse the recommendations of the report and insisted he would not stand over any downgrading of Nenagh Hospital. Where does this leave the Minister for Health (Mr Martin)?" - Labour Party Spokeswoman on Health, Ms Liz McManus to the Dáil.
November 12th:
"Members here have no idea what the Minister for Defence, Deputy Smith, said on the night, and what he said subsequently because they did not even listen to the reports. The Minister totally accepts the Hanly report."
- Taoiseach Mr Ahern to the Dáil.
"In the discussion about demographics and geographics, people are entitled to put forward their views. The Minister for Defence totally accepts that." - Taoiseach Mr Ahern, speaking during Dáil exchanges.
"There is no need to sacrifice people who live in the outlying areas who feel threatened and worried.There is no need to sacrifice them on the altar of the Hanly report." - Mr Smith, speaking in a radio interview a few hours later.
November 13th
"Minister Smith will definitely be standing in the next general election. He is not afraid of any Government reshuffle and his only interest is in ensuring the best services for Nenagh Hospital and the people of North Tipperary."
- Spokesman for Mr Smith.
"Michael knew how far he could go and get away with it, and did it."- an anonymous Fianna Fáil backbencher.