Regularising legal position of migrants ‘could generate €185m’

Vast majority of undocumented migrants entered the State legally

A scheme to regularise the legal position of about 26,000 undocumented migrants, including up to 5,000 undocumented children, could generate "a potential €185 million over five years", an Oireachtas committee was told yesterday.

Helen Lowry, a community worker with the Migrant Rights Centre of Ireland (MRCI), addressed the committee on justice, in the company of Jayson Montenegro, an undocumented worker from the Philippines.

Mr Montenegro is also one of the six original founders in 2010 of Justice for the Undocumented, which now has more than 900 members. Ms Lowry said the vast majority of undocumented migrants had entered the State legally. They lived in constant fear of being “caught”, could not report crimes against them, and many had “real heartbreak in their lives” due to being unable to go home to see their families.

Undocumented migrants

A recent MRCI survey of 540 undocumented migrants found some 81 per cent had been here for five years or longer, with 40 per cent here for more than eight years. Some 87 per cent were working and 65 per cent had been in their current job for more than five years. The main sectors they were working in were catering, care work, domestic work and maintenance.


"The people we work with have the same struggles, hopes and dreams as undocumented Irish in the United States. They too would like to be able to return home to see their loved ones," said Ms Lowry.

Mr Montenegro said he came to Ireland in 2003 having been promised a work permit. He left his wife and family when his youngest child was aged five. He has not seen his son, now 17, since. He realised after a number of years he would not get a work permit and he remains undocumented, working as a carer. The remittances he has sent home have paid for his children’s education, including putting his two daughters through college.

See his family

“I miss my children. I miss them growing up. At Christmas my son asked, ‘Do I know you dad?’ My life stopped when he asked this question because I didn’t know how to answer it. I always say I am doing this for your future.” The first thing he would do if he was regularised would be to go and see his family. The MRCI is calling for a scheme to regularise undocumented people who have been here for four years or more, though those with criminal convictions would be barred. They would pay an administrative fee, which would bring in up to €11.5 million.

The exchequer would also gain about €7.5 million as these workers would all be paying taxes and employers paying PRSI contributions would bring in up to €20 million a year. Ongoing immigration registration fees would generate up to €5 million per year. “In total this scheme has the potential to generate €185 million over five years,” said Ms Lowry.

Kitty Holland

Kitty Holland

Kitty Holland is Social Affairs Correspondent of The Irish Times