Private school teachers ‘are treated like second-class citizens’

ASTI delegates hear staff in fee-paying schools are paid well below official rates

Teachers at many of the State’s fee-paying schools are treated like “second-class citizens” and paid well below official rates, a teachers’ union conference has been told.

Delegates at the annual convention of the Association of Secondary Teachers Ireland (ASTI) heard many teachers at these schools are privately paid out of the schools ’ resources.

As a result they are not covered by official pay scales which apply to the wider profession.

Joe Moran, a member of ASTI's Tipperary branch, said there was a perception that fee-paying schools were the preserve of the privileged, but this did not apply to teachers.


A significant number of teachers in them had little prospect of securing permanent work and were excluded from pension schemes and benefits.

Many of these teachers were involved in significant amounts of unpaid extra-curricular activity, such as drama and sports. In some cases they were working alongside paid coaches.

Niall Mahon, another delegate, said there were many misconceptions over the way these teachers were treated.

Quaffing claret

“We’re not sitting on leather sofas, quaffing claret . . . Yes, there are good grounds, a bigger subject choice, but these teachers are not being paid [the same as other teachers].”

The ASTI took a successful claim to the Employment Appeals Tribunal seeking pay parity for privately paid teachers.

However, it was overturned by the High Court following an appeal by the Catholic University School, a private Dublin school.

The court ruled pay rates for privately paid teachers should be compared to other privately paid teachers rather than those employed by the State. Union officials yesterday said there remains a possibility of the issue being brought to Europe.

Noel Buckley, a member of the union's central executive committee, said it was a "dark area" of the education sector which needed to be highlighted.

“The reality is many of these teachers are afraid to put their voice out there; they are afraid it will affect their future working conditions.”


Brendan Broderick

, another delegate, said while many of these schools were elitist, they “treated their staff as second-class citizens”.

Enda Whelton, a member of the union's standing committee, said the issue could have wider implications for the broader membership.

If Department of Education proposals to give greater autonomy to schools were followed through, it could lead to more privately paid teachers.

“In light of ‘school autonomy’, this is what it will look like for all teachers,” he said.

“Some don’t even know what they get paid . . . they get a package deal to do other jobs in the school . . . They are in a very, very vulnerable position.”

Mary Ohle, another delegate, said some of those on full-time hours were on a salary of about €21,000, about €10,000 below the department's rate for new entrants on full-time contracts.

“Many don’t see the point of joining a trade union when their pay is worse than that of newly qualified teachers.”

Delegates unanimously supported a motion that the ASTI establish a committee to oversee the pay and conditions of privately paid teachers.

Carl O'Brien

Carl O'Brien

Carl O'Brien is Education Editor of The Irish Times. He was previously chief reporter and social affairs correspondent