Advertising Feature
An advertising feature is created, supplied and paid for by a commercial client and promoted by the Irish Times Content Studio. The Irish Times newsroom or other editorial departments are not involved in the production of advertising features.

Mark Little: ‘The attention economy is bankrupt’

Entrepreneur, author and former RTÉ presenter Mark Little tells Dentsu’s Dave Winterlich why, even if its best day is behind it, he has high hopes for a more intimate internet

In Mark Little's new book, The Last Good Day on the Internet, he tracks a trend towards frequenting safer, smaller spaces on the internet
In Mark Little's new book, The Last Good Day on the Internet, he tracks a trend towards frequenting safer, smaller spaces on the internet

Remember the furore over that dress on the internet, the one that was either black and blue or white and gold? For tech expert Mark Little it marked the last time we participated en masse in an internet phenomenon.

The former Prime Time presenter and founder of Storyful, the world’s first social news agency, as well as Kinzen, a platform to detect online harm, says people assume the title of his new book, The Last Good Day on the Internet, is a metaphor. Not so. “It’s an actual day: the 26th February, 2015,” he tells Winterlich.

“It’s the day that the world lost its marbles over a dress. For that moment in time, the internet just grabbed us. As we left our devices that night, we felt more human because we’d been connected to a shared reality. Even though it was just fun, it made you feel more alive rather than less, as our experience is now.”

After that the supercharged algorithms that power surveillance capitalism started to kick in. “We were never really allowed to have another shared reality moment after that day, because these algorithms have forced us into these small, hyper-personalised filter bubbles where we’re bombarded now with advertising and with artificial experiences,” says Little.

It wasn’t advertising’s fault, or at least, not all. “I don’t think it was advertising itself. I think it was the incentives that kicked in at a certain point, that last good day on the internet,” says Little.

Advertising helped turn the internet from an academic project with US military origins in the mid-1990s, “into something that really did expand and scale, and suddenly we had a marketplace, and that was hugely healthy”, he says. This halcyon phase was a “mixed economy” of community and decentralised volunteers on one side, and businesses on the other, funding and founding websites.

Then, “what happens is Google decide they have the algorithm that can now hyper-personalise our eyeballs and suddenly, they come along with what is a bargain that no advertiser” is going to turn down, he says. That is, “I can sell you, by the billions, the eyeballs of people” but only for “the blink of a second”.

It gives rise to recommender systems, which he describes as “essentially surveillance”, a machine-driven process which picks an advertisement to put in front of internet users, in a programmatic marketplace with no human involvement. “It takes less than a blink of an eye and we lose control,” he says. “We become completely and utterly unconscious of how it all works for about 10 years – until now.”

He likens it to the old saw about no one ever getting fired for buying IBM. Only this time around, “no advertiser ever got fired for doing a big deal with Google,” he says.

Not alone could very few online platforms actually stand over the performance of such ads, he says, but what was really damaging was that it drove our worst instincts. It gave us “what the big platforms call our ‘revealed preferences’, but actually, they’re not what we wanted,” he says. “They didn’t give us our best intentions, they just mined our worst instincts, and that became the attention economy. That’s the problem, not necessarily the advertising itself.”

‘Younger audiences are backing away from anything that feels mass market-cringey. They are going to safer, smaller spaces’

—  Mark Little

If we could get a do over, he’d go back and integrate micro payments into the internet from the very start, he says, and monetise apps in a way that would lead to deeper engagement. Unfortunately, that didn’t happen and instead, the internet became all about data and doomscrolling.

By contrast, algorithms such as Spotify’s or Netflix’s are about building lifetime value and loyalty, “a much more impactful and, I would argue, healthy ecosystem that we could have built from scratch,” he says. Instead we are only now moving out of the age of attention.

“The attention economy is bankrupt. It’s hanging on by a thread. It’s not going to go away, we’ll still need platforms, and places like YouTube are still a juggernaut, but there is a new ‘intention economy’ where we can actually start to get better signals [of] what people really want, not just their kind of worst instincts. That is where the hope, I think, lies,” he says. “We have a second chance that we missed first time around.”

As a serial entrepreneur, Little is optimistic by nature. “The biggest problem right now in media generally, in advertising and publishing, is inertia. We’re like Wile E Coyote. We know we’ve run off the side of a cliff, but we haven’t yet been caught by gravity, we don’t know what is below us,” he explains. “So we’re all doing our very, very best to make the most we can of this model we have right now, that we know is doomed. I think we all know it but we just don’t know what the next thing is.”

He points to the emerging intention economy, explaining how, for example, his own daughter is not interested in €3 T-shirts made in a sweatshop, choosing instead to buy from a community of her peers on second-hand websites such as Vinted and Depop, and support the circular economy.

“She finds comfort in human connection,” he says. “When intelligence is everywhere, what is scarce? It is you and me right now, that is the scarce thing – communication and connections.”

There is now a yearning for that. “It’s why younger audiences are backing away from anything that feels mass market-cringey. They are going to safer, smaller spaces. We’re moving from an internet of the social platform to the internet of the group chat. And that group chat is now much more intimate. Everybody in the group chat has your back,” he says.

What he calls these “human settlements” are increasingly starting to emerge on the internet, outside of the reach of the algorithms.

For brands, being in these more intimate spaces will be key, and a route that will see them make “more of their money from a smaller number of people”, he says.

“As people get more intentional and start seeking out smaller, safer communities, then you are talking about platforms that maybe you’d forgotten about, like Reddit, or relatively new platforms like Discord,” he says.

“Suddenly, the more intimate internet becomes way more valuable to you. I think that’s the frame of mind of all the best media professionals - the journalists, the ones that have embraced that and left newsrooms to become solopreneurs on Substack or YouTube. So look at those people and see what they are doing right and I think you might get a sense of where advertising is going as well,” he says.

Discover more Inside Marketing podcast episodes at irishtimes.com


IN THIS SECTION