Subscriber OnlyLetters

New €3 customs charge a blunt levy

Expecting consumers to be aware of subtle nuances implicit in the charge is unrealistic

Letters to the Editor. Illustration: Paul Scott
The Irish Times - Letters to the Editor.

Sir, – Since July 1st, a new €3 customs charge applies to packages worth €150 or less arriving from outside the European Union.

On the surface, the aim is understandable and a worthwhile cause: to help retailers compete against low-cost foreign platforms.

However, Ireland is particularly affected by this approach. We have a relatively small domestic market, meaning many niche or specialist products are simply unavailable locally. Even shopping through places like Amazon Ireland offers no real protection, as many items are still dispatched from Britain and still subject to the charge.

The implementation can have some very unexpected results. Because the charge applies per distinct product type rather than per package, buying three pairs of cotton socks incurs a single €3 charge. However, buying separate wool, cotton, and synthetic pairs costs a whopping €9 because they are treated as different product types in the customs tariff database.

It is completely unrealistic to expect consumers to be aware of all these nuances. Worse still, while large online platforms like Amazon have the systems to collect these charges at checkout, many smaller independent retailers do not.

For those of us who want to support small family businesses rather than multinationals, your package coming from outside the EU is likely to be held by An Post, which will add the charge plus an additional €6.95 processing fee.

For many low-value purchases, the fees could easily exceed the total price of the items.

If the aim is to strengthen local businesses, in my mind a more consumer-friendly approach would be targeted incentives like tax relief on domestic purchases rather than a blanket penalty on items that might not have any realistic alternative. – Yours, etc,

PETER ELST,

Donabate,

Dublin.