Stanford judge removed from new sexual assault case
District attorney says he lacks ‘confidence’ that judge can ‘fairly participate’ in the case
Activists hold signs calling for the removal of Judge Aaron Persky from the bench after his controversial sentencing in the Stanford rape case, in San Francisco, California. Photograph: Stephen Lam/Reuters
The California judge facing criticism over his sentencing of a former Stanford University swimmer convicted of sexual assault was removed on Tuesday from a new sexual assault case after complaints by prosecutors, officials said.
“We lack confidence that Judge (Aaron) Persky can fairly participate in this upcoming hearing in which a male nurse sexually assaulted an anaesthetised female patient,” Santa Clara County district attorney Jeff Rosen said in a statement.
He called the move “rare and carefully considered.”
Mr Rosen cited the six-month jail sentence Judge Persky handed down to Brock Turner (20) earlier this month following the former swimmer’s conviction for sexually assaulting an unconscious woman after a party in January 2015. Prosecutors sought a six-year prison term.
Turner was convicted of assault with intent to commit rape, penetration of an intoxicated and unconscious person. Under California law, those charges are not considered rape because they did not involve penile penetration.
Stacey Capps, chief trial deputy for the district attorney’s office, said the new case was reassigned to another judge and a hearing was held on Tuesday afternoon.
She said that the victim being “particularly vulnerable” was factored into the move.
Ms Capps said that in the new case, Cecil Webb stands accused of touching the vagina and breast of a woman who was anaesthetised ahead of a surgery at a Santa Clara hospital in November 2014.
Webb has pleaded not guilty and his attorney could not be immediately reached for comment.
A juror in the Stanford University sexual assault case wrote to Judge Persky saying he was disappointed and “vehemently” disagreed with the June 2nd sentence, according to the letter, which was posted online late on Monday by the Palo Alto Weekly newspaper.
“I expected that this case would serve as a very strong deterrent to on-campus assaults but with the ridiculously lenient sentence, I am afraid that it makes a mockery of the whole trial,” the juror wrote, concluding the letter with “shame on you.”
Judge Persky is prohibited from commenting on the case because Turner is appealing his conviction, a spokesman for Santa Clara County superior court has said.
Turner’s sentencing drew criticism after the publication of a letter the victim read in court, detailing the devastation she felt from the assault. A Stanford law professor is leading a drive to gather signatures for a petition to remove Persky.