Dying from overwork: Strain on South Korea’s delivery workers gets too much

Nine couriers have died this year as Covid demands and poor protections take their toll

Couriers raise their fists while singing a union song at a depot in Seoul, South Korea. Photograph:  Woohae Cho/The New York Times

Couriers raise their fists while singing a union song at a depot in Seoul, South Korea. Photograph: Woohae Cho/The New York Times

Your Web Browser may be out of date. If you are using Internet Explorer 9, 10 or 11 our Audio player will not work properly.
For a better experience use Google Chrome, Firefox or Microsoft Edge.

 

At a logistics depot the size of an aeroplane hangar in southern Seoul, couriers recently held a ritual at the start of another gruelling work day: They stood for a moment of silence to remember more than a dozen fellow couriers who they say died this year from overwork.

“We won’t be surprised here if one of us drops dead, too,” said Choi Ji-na, one of the couriers.

Choi (43) and other delivery workers in South Korea say that they feel lucky to have jobs amid growing unemployment, and that they are proud to play an essential role in keeping the country’s Covid-19 cases down by delivering record numbers of packages to customers who prefer to stay safe at home.

But they are also paying a price. The string of deaths among couriers this year has caused a national uproar, drawing attention to worker protections that are unevenly distributed in a place that once had one of the longest work weeks in the world.

Packages are expected to arrive with “bullet speed”, but the uninsured workers delivering them say that it is becoming impossible to keep up with the demand, and that labour rule changes made by President Moon Jae-in have left them out in the cold.

There have been 15 deaths among couriers so far, including some who died after complaining of unbearable workloads that kept them on the clock from dawn until past midnight. The delivery workers say they’re dying of “gwarosa”, or death by overwork.

“The workload has become just too much,” Choi said. “Since the coronavirus came, going home early enough to have dinner with my children has become a distant dream.”

Least protected

Couriers are some of the hardest-working, least protected workers in South Korea. Between 2015 and 2019, only one to four couriers died per year. This year, nine couriers died in the first half of the year alone, according to data that the Korea Occupational Safety and Health Agency submitted to the lawmaker Yong Hye-in.

When Moon slashed the maximum work week to 52 hours from 68 in 2018 to ensure a “work-life balance” and a “right to rest”, couriers were left out of the deal. As the pandemic rages on and packages pile up, couriers say they are not only facing longer hours but also an ever-present fear that they will succumb to the mounting volume of work.

Couriers check delivery addresses at a distribution centre in Seoul. Photograph: Woohae Cho/The New York Times
Couriers check delivery addresses at a distribution centre in Seoul. Photograph: Woohae Cho/The New York Times

Online orders have surged around the world, and demand for delivered goods in South Korea has grown by 30 per cent, to 3.6 billion parcels this year, according to some estimates. Most deliveries in South Korea are handled by large logistics companies.

Those firms outsource the labour to couriers, who are independent subcontractors working on commission using their own trucks in assigned areas. Since 1997, as e-commerce as boomed and competition has intensified, online shipping costs in the country have dropped by more than half.

Some residents who fear infection have refused to share lifts with delivery workers, forcing them to haul packages up stairs.

Shopping malls and logistics firms now promise even faster deliveries, offering “within-the-day”, “before-dawn” and “bullet-speed” options. But the fees collected by couriers have dropped. Workers now receive between 60 and 80 cents per parcel and have been slapped with penalties when they fail to meet delivery deadlines set by major online shopping retailers.

‘Just too tired’

One courier in Seoul, Kim Dong-hee, returned home at 2am on October 7th. Later that day, he returned to the warehouse to pick up 420 packages. He still had many deliveries to make when he texted a colleague at 4.28am the next day. He said he would be home by 5am but would barely have time to eat and wash up before heading out again.

“I am just too tired,” he wrote.

Four days later, he didn’t show up for work. When colleagues checked his home, they found him dead; police ruled that heart failure was the cause.

Colleagues say he was killed by overwork. He was 36. The day that Kim sent his message, another man in Seoul, Kim Won-jong, collapsed on his delivery route, complaining of chest pain and difficulty breathing before he died.

“I remember how tired he looked late in the evening, his shoulders slumped and his cap pulled low, as if he were semiconscious,” a customer who knew Kim wrote online after his death made news.

It has become common to see weary couriers weaving through apartment compounds in the dead of night, delivering fruit, bottled water, Christmas decorations and other items that many shoppers now prefer to have delivered. Some residents who fear infection have refused to share lifts with delivery workers, forcing them to haul packages up stairs.

Park Ki-Ryeon delivers bags of rice to customers in Seongnam, a city on the outskirts of Seoul. Photograph: Woohae Cho/The New York Times
Park Ki-Ryeon delivers bags of rice to customers in Seongnam, a city on the outskirts of Seoul. Photograph: Woohae Cho/The New York Times

The pandemic has brought profits to couriers and logistics companies like CJ Logistics, Hanjin Shipping and Lotte. But categorised as self-employed, most of the country’s estimated 54,000 “taekbae gisa”, or home-delivery drivers, do not benefit from the labour laws that protect full-time corporate employees. Benefits such as overtime, paid leave and insurance against on-the-job injuries are largely unavailable.

Couriers have been known to injure their ankles or become the subject of police calls made by neighbours who mistake them for burglars.

According to a September survey by the Center for Workers’ Health and Safety, a rights group, couriers work an average of 12 hours a day, six days a week. According to government data submitted to lawmakers, work-related injuries for couriers soared by 43 per cent in the first half of the year.

‘Life with evenings’

Couriers in the United States, Europe and China have gone on strike seeking better protections. In South Korea, they have staged strikes hoping to secure shorter hours and a “life with evenings”.

“We organised and fought back because we had no one to talk to,” said Park Ki-ryeon (36), a courier since 2016.

“We, too would like to keep warm indoors, like the people we serve,” Park said. “But many of us are not well educated and started this work with debts to pay. If we quit, we don’t have an alternative.”

Choi became a delivery worker seven years ago after a divorce made her a single mother of two young children. She has hauled packages weighing up to 25kg apiece up and down stairs. She sometimes has to climb walls to make deliveries, because homeowners are out, with their gates locked, but want the parcels left inside.

Couriers have been known to injure their ankles or become the subject of police calls made by neighbours who mistake them for burglars.

She said she liked the work because she could get home in time for her children to return from school, but the virus changed everything. Choi now delivers up to 370 parcels a day, 30 per cent more than before the pandemic. She starts work at 6.30am and rarely gets home before 10pm.

At the depot, container trucks rumbled in under the pre-dawn sky, bringing cargo from across South Korea. As what seemed like an endless stream of parcels of all shapes and sizes were unloaded, Choi and her colleagues gathered around a conveyor belt to search for packages with addresses in their districts.

The deliveries would stretch well into the night.

Apologies

Some logistics companies have apologised for the recent spate of deaths and promised to provide benefits, like medical check-ups, and add more workers in phases to help shorten work hours and manage the increased volume.

Moon’s government has vowed to introduce a five-day work week and ban night-time deliveries, admitting that his policies have not kept up with the growth of the delivery industry and that “the burden was concentrated in long hours and heavy workloads for couriers”.

After the deaths generated headlines, people also began expressing sympathy for the couriers, leaving drinks and snacks at the door with notes saying, “It’s okay to be late.”

“When strangers pass me on the streets, they say to me, ‘Please don’t die! We need you,’” Park said. But the reforms promised by logistics companies and the government have been too slow to arrive.

When his grandmother died last month, Park said, he had to hire a replacement courier with his own money to deliver the parcels along his route just so he could take a half day off to mourn her.

“We want change,” he said. “We are not working machines.” – New York Times

The Irish Times Logo
Commenting on The Irish Times has changed. To comment you must now be an Irish Times subscriber.
SUBSCRIBE
GO BACK
Error Image
The account details entered are not currently associated with an Irish Times subscription. Please subscribe to sign in to comment.
Comment Sign In

Forgot password?
The Irish Times Logo
Thank you
You should receive instructions for resetting your password. When you have reset your password, you can Sign In.
The Irish Times Logo
Please choose a screen name. This name will appear beside any comments you post. Your screen name should follow the standards set out in our community standards.
Screen Name Selection

Hello

Please choose a screen name. This name will appear beside any comments you post. Your screen name should follow the standards set out in our community standards.

The Irish Times Logo
Commenting on The Irish Times has changed. To comment you must now be an Irish Times subscriber.
SUBSCRIBE
Forgot Password
Please enter your email address so we can send you a link to reset your password.

Sign In

Your Comments
We reserve the right to remove any content at any time from this Community, including without limitation if it violates the Community Standards. We ask that you report content that you in good faith believe violates the above rules by clicking the Flag link next to the offending comment or by filling out this form. New comments are only accepted for 3 days from the date of publication.