Government concern about UK plan to scrap Human Rights Act

Dublin to warn Tories it may breach Belfast Agreement terms and threaten stability

The Government has serious concerns that London could breach the terms of the Belfast Agreement if prime minister David Cameron carries through on a pledge to scrap the UK's Human Rights Act.

Minister for Foreign Affairs Charlie Flanagan said any British plans to repeal the Act and curtail the role of the European Court of Human Rights would be "a matter of some concern" and will raise the issue at a meeting with Northern Ireland Secretary Theresa Villiers.

Irish officials privately fear scrapping the Act could have major implications for the Belfast Agreement and related bilateral deals between the UK and Ireland. They believe the Tories’ overall majority has made repeal more likely.

Long-standing objective

The 1998 agreement expressly committed London to incorporating the European Convention on Human Rights into


Northern Ireland

law, providing direct access to the courts and allowing judges to overrule Northern Assembly legislation on grounds of inconsistency with human rights law. Tony Blair’s


government complied by enacting the Human Rights Act, but getting rid of it has been a long-standing objective of the Conservatives.

This has provoked alarm in Dublin and Belfast, where the agreement's human rights provisions are seen as having been key to winning nationalist support for the deal. The Irish Human Rights and Equality Commission said it was "monitoring developments" while its sister commission in Northern Ireland said the British move was "deeply concerning".

Mr Flanagan said the protection of human rights, predicated on the European convention, was “one of the key principles” underpinning the accord. “As a guarantor of the Good Friday agreement, the Irish Government takes very seriously our responsibility to safeguard the agreement. The fundamental role of human rights in guaranteeing peace and stability in Northern Ireland must be fully respected,” he said.

Sinn Féin president Gerry Adams warned that the plan to repeal the act was "a direct attack" on the Belfast Agreement and called on Taoiseach Enda Kenny to urgently raise the matter with Mr Cameron.

Ruadhán Mac Cormaic

Ruadhán Mac Cormaic

Ruadhán Mac Cormaic is the Editor of The Irish Times