DUP in dilemma over whether to take education ministry

Sinn Féin also mulling over whether to first opt for economy portfolio

The DUP has first choice of which ministry to take in the new Northern Executive which is scheduled to be formed in two weeks' time. Sinn Féin will have the second choice.

The DUP, as deputy leader Nigel Dodds conceded, is faced with the dilemma of choosing the finance department, as it has done in the past, or opting for the economy or education departments.

Mr Dodds said at the weekend that the party would take time to decide which portfolio to take on first, while acknowledging it faces a hard choice between finance, education and the economy.

The new Northern Executive is slimmed down from 12 to nine departments. The Office of First Minister and Deputy First Minister is re-titled the Executive Office which is shared with Arlene Foster as First Minister and Martin McGuinness as Deputy First Minister.


While there are eight full departments to be allocated, seven of them will be awarded under the d’Hondt system of appointing ministers. This is a system where departments are allocated based on the proportional strengths of the parties.

Under d'Hondt, the DUP is entitled to four ministries, Sinn Fein to three and one each to the Ulster Unionist Party and the SDLP.

Alliance, which won eight seats in the Assembly election, does not have sufficient strength to be allocated a department under d’Hondt. It, however, has a very good chance of taking the justice portfolio which is outside the d’Hondt process.

That is because, mutually, neither the DUP nor Sinn Fein, which dominate the Executive, is likely to accept a Minister from either party in charge of justice.

There is a possibility that the two parties could agree to rotate the department over the lifetime of the Assembly, but a more likely scenario may be that it will apply the compromise agreed in 2010 where Alliance, which is designated as neither unionist nor nationalist, takes the post.

The outgoing minister of justice and Alliance leader David Ford said he is standing down from that role. He said that either Naomi Long, who was elected in East Belfast, or Dr Stephen Farry, who was returned in North Down, would be in line for the job if Alliance had the taking of the department.

The DUP is under pressure from some supporters to take over education which, since 1999, apart from periods of suspension, has been in the hands of Sinn Féin.

Mr Dodds indicated it would be difficult for his party to forego finance because the department "holds the purse strings" of Stormont.

Equally, however, there is a chance that as its first choice that Sinn Féin might opt for the economy rather than education. A possible contender here if that does happen is South Belfast MLA Mairtin Ó Muilleoir, who also is a publisher and businessman.

In such an eventuality, the DUP as first choice could opt for finance and then take education. North Antrim MLA Mervyn Storey is the current minister for finance and could be in line for that post again. Current minister for health Simon Hamilton could move to education in such a scenario.

Under d’Hondt, the DUP will have first, third and sixth choice of ministries and Sinn Fein will have second and fifth choices. Assuming they enter into the Executive rather than go into opposition, the Ulster Unionist Party will have fourth choice and the SDLP will have seventh (and last) choice.

In such a case, the UUP could take health with UUP leader Mike Nesbitt having to decide whether he wants to take on a ministry or hand it to a colleague, such as former regional development Minister Danny Kennedy, or some other party member.

SDLP leader Colum Eastwood will be faced with the same decision with his choice.

Other possible contenders for preferment include outgoing DUP junior minister Emma Pengelly and outgoing DUP regional development minister Michelle McIlveen; and outgoing Sinn Féin ministers John O'Dowd, Caral Ní Chuilin and Michelle O'Neill.

Gerry Moriarty

Gerry Moriarty

Gerry Moriarty is the former Northern editor of The Irish Times