Dún Laoghaire cruise ship facilities to be subject of court appeal

Save our Seafront to claim Bord Pleanála had no right to permit alternative development

A judicial review of An Bord Pleanála’s decision to approve cruise ship facilities in Dún Laoghaire harbour will be sought in the High Court on Thursday.

The campaign group Save our Seafront, which is taking the challenge, says last November’s decision by Bord Pleanála restricted the size of ships but still left open the possibility of the harbour being usurped by cruise liners.

The board granted permission to Dún Laoghaire Harbour Company for an €18 million development to build a new pier and dredge a navigation channel through the harbour mouth, as well as developing a turning circle outside the harbour. But the board ruled the size of ships permitted to enter the harbour should be restricted to 250m in length, rather than the 340m limit sought by the company.

The chairman of Save Our Seafront, local TD Richard Boyd Barrett of the Anti-Austerity Alliance-People Before Profit, said the development approved by the board could still result in a significant loss of amenity to existing harbour users. He said the board’s decision did not properly take into account the environmental implications of dredging and other aspects of the plan.

Save our Seafront is to ask the court to grant a judicial review of the decision on the basis of two points.

Environmental effects

It claims the environmental impact study (EIS) and the natural impact statement were inadequate and failed to capture the environmental effects of the proposed development.

The group also claims Bord Pleanála has granted permission for a development for which the harbour company did not apply. The group will submit that Bord Pleanála has no general jurisdiction to grant consent for a development materially different from that for which permission was sought.

It will also claim Bord Pleanála has no jurisdiction to grant consent in respect of a development for which an EIS has not been submitted. A number of other grounds are also expected to be raised.

Mr Boyd Barrett said:“A giant cruise berth in Dún Laoghaire harbour would negatively impact on all users of the harbour – walkers, boat-users and the varied wildlife. Our harbour is a wonderfully historic and cultural asset and should be developed to enhance all aspects of our harbour rather than limiting it to giant cruise ships.

“We are applying for a judicial review in order to protect Dún Laoghaire harbour for the people and the natural environment.”