Resignation Statement Of Mr Justice Hugh O'Flaherty

In regard to the recent controversy surrounding my actions I accept that the appearance of detachment must be the most important…

In regard to the recent controversy surrounding my actions I accept that the appearance of detachment must be the most important thing for a Judge and there cannot be a scintilla of suspicion to call in question his impartiality.

I did not believe or consider that what I did was wrong in contacting the County Registrar about the Sheedy case. I accept, however, the Chief Justice's conclusion that what I did was open to misinterpretation and it was this perception that led him to conclude that damage was done to the administration of justice.

The highest duty of a Judge is impartiality, as well as the appearance of impartiality, and as my last duty and so that confidence can be restored in the administration of justice I have decided to offer my resignation as Judge of the Supreme Court.

I have been a servant of the legal system for forty years, over nine years as a Judge. That the integrity of the legal system is preserved is in keeping with what I have worked for all my professional life.

READ MORE

Accordingly, I have today placed my resignation in the hand of the President. This has been a difficult time for my wife and family who have undergone enormous strain. We would ask for a measure of privacy in the weeks ahead until everyone has time to reflect in a calmer atmosphere and the courts are allowed to get on with their business.

Saturday 17th April, 1999