Gerald Kean settles additional claim against newspaper
High Court found last week solicitor had been defamed by article in Irish Daily Star
Gerald Kean pictured at the Four Courts last week for a High Court action. Photograph: Collins Courts
No details of the settlement were outlined when the matter was mentioned before Mr Justice Bernard Barton on Wednesday.
Last week, a High Court jury, by a majority of at least nine , awarded Mr Kean €160,000 damages against Independent Star Ltd after finding he was defamed in an Irish Daily Star article of March 11th 2016 concerning a visit by members of the Criminal Assets Bureau to his Dublin offices.
The majority found the article, headlined ‘Kean Caught up in CAB probe’, meant Mr Kean was subject of a probe by CAB into the criminal activities of the Hutch and Kinahan gangs following the Regency Hotel shootings of February 2016 and defamed him.
After rejecting arguments by the newspaper that the article concerned a matter of public interest and it was “fair and reasonable” to publish it, they decided Mr Kean was entitled to damages of €160,000.
Mr Kean was also awarded his costs by Mr Justice Barton.
The matter was adjourned to Wednesday when the judge was due to deal with a separate claim by Mr Kean alleging that the article breached his constitutional right to privacy. That claim was not before the jury for determination.
The newspaper had also indicated to the judge, after the verdict last week, that it was considering whether to appeal the jury decision and to seek a stay on the damages order in the event of any such appeal.
On Wednesday, the judge was told by Paul O’Higgins SC, with Jim O’Callaghan SC, for Mr Kean, that “peace has broken out” and the entire proceedings had been settled.
Counsel said the only order required was one striking out the entire proceedings with an order for taxation of Mr Kean’s costs, to include reserved costs and discovery and stenography, in default of agreement.
The judge said he would make those orders.
Eoin McCullough SC, for Independent Star, said such cases are “invariably difficult” and he thanked the judge for the time and courtesy afforded to the sides.