Stocktake: Foundation of the market is ‘fragile’

Breadth was also weak in 2018, resulting in a 20 per cent correction later that year

Morgan Stanley’s Mike Wilson says we have ‘never witnessed breadth this weak with major indices at all-time highs’. Photograph: Lucas Jackson/Reuters
Morgan Stanley’s Mike Wilson says we have ‘never witnessed breadth this weak with major indices at all-time highs’. Photograph: Lucas Jackson/Reuters

US stocks are near all-time highs but weak market breadth continues to concern.

Even as the cap-weighted S&P 500 hit fresh highs last Tuesday, an equal-weighted version of the index fell almost 1 per cent (the equal-weight index weighs all 500 stocks in the index equally, whereas the cap-weighted version is dominated by the most valuable companies, like Apple and Microsoft).

Although the S&P 500 has hit multiple new highs over the last two months, its equal-weight counterpart has gone nowhere over the same period, notes Bespoke Investment.

Weak breadth is "potentially serious", says CFRA Research's Sam Stovall, as mega-cap strength is "masking growing internal weakness".

The same point is stressed by Morgan Stanley’s Mike Wilson, who says we’ve “never witnessed breadth this weak with major indices at all-time highs”. Markets have taken on a “much more defensive posture” under the surface, which Wilson characterises as a “rolling correction” with the most speculative assets tumbling from their highs.

The current environment reminds Wilson of 2018, when breadth was also weak and which eventually resulted in a 20 per cent correction in December.

“The foundation of the market is fragile,” says Wilson. “It needs to strengthen or else the major averages are vulnerable.”

  • Join The Irish Times on WhatsApp and stay up to date

  • Find managing your money a struggle? The Better with Money podcast will guide you on how to control your finances

  • Get the On the Money newsletter for insights on saving money and smart spending decisions

Proinsias O'Mahony

Proinsias O'Mahony

Proinsias O’Mahony, a contributor to The Irish Times, writes the weekly Stocktake column