Government steps back from tinkering with Bank of Mum and Dad

Amendments also deal with tax treatment of non-cash prizes in raffles and draws

The Government has stepped back from planned changes to the tax treatment of family loans that could eat into tax-free thresholds on inheritance.

Known as the Bank of Mum and Dad, such low-interest loans are frequently used by families looking to give a financial hand-up to children when it comes to big ticket purchases, such as cars, home purchase or renovations.

Although tax law does not oblige family members to charge one another interest on loans, the value of the interest that the parent forgoes by lending the money rather than saving it has been seen as a taxable benefit.

"Where a child receives a loan from a parent for which they pay nothing" – which is to say as an interest-free loan – "or where they pay interest at a rate less than the open-market interest rate, the annual value of the loan to the child may be treated as a taxable gift in each year that the loan is in place", a Revenue spokeswoman said.


That taxable benefit is set against a lifetime tax-free limit on gifts and inheritances if it amounts to more than €3,000 in any given year.

Finance Bill

The Finance Bill, which puts into legal force measures announced in the budget and which is currently going through the Oireachtas, had amended the existing rules so that "the best price obtainable in the open market for the use or enjoyment of money shall be equal to the best price obtainable of borrowing an equivalent amount of money in the open market".

That means it would be assessed against the cost of borrowing the same money from a bank or credit union. Until now, the benchmark rate has been the rate available on savings in an Irish bank. However, with interest rates on savings now hovering around zero, the Finance Bill had looked to change the benchmark.

In a statement on Friday, Minister for Finance Paschal Donohoe said he had decided "not to proceed with section 62 of the [Finance] Bill relating to the tax treatment of interest-free or low-interest loans as he believes greater consideration needs to be given to the proposal".

That “consideration” will have to address several complexities in determining which bank lending rate should be used in assessing the interest forgone by the parent.

Interest rates on loans are affected by multiple variables. These include whether you are borrowing for a mortgage or a general personal loan. Mortgage interest rates are also affected by the financial position of the borrower and the amount they wish to borrow as a proportion of the property price and the period for which the interest rate is fixed.

The proposed measure had been criticised by people in the financial services and advisory sectors as being unduly complex and unworkable.

Raffle prizes

Other amendments put forward by the Government on Friday include confirmation that non-cash prizes in raffles and draws would have the same exemption from capital acquisitions tax as cash winnings.

However, a separate amendment means that people selling their home by raffle will enjoy only the traditional exemption from capital gains up to the market value of the property.

If someone raises €500,000 in a raffle for a home with a market value of €350,000, €150,000 of that money will be taxed under capital gains at 33 per cent.

Some technical amendments have also been put forward relating to the new Residential Zoned Land Tax, including one that will see the land being forfeited to the State where an owner cannot be identified and the tax and interest due exceeds 110 per cent of the site’s market value.

A separate amendment confirms that the new higher USC threshold for the 2 per cent rate – it is rising by €608 to €21,295 – will apply for the whole of 2022.

Dominic Coyle

Dominic Coyle

Dominic Coyle is Deputy Business Editor of The Irish Times