Denis O’Brien ‘delighted’ after winning RTÉ injunction
Injunction prevents RTÉ broadcasting dealings with IBRC
Denis O’Brien: ‘I believe that every citizen is entitled to privacy in their financial affairs.’ Photograph: Dara Mac Donaill / The Irish Times
The bank has also secured an injunction against the broadcaster in relation to the proposed report, which was to have included information that was also contained in legal advice drafted by the bank’s solicitors.
Mr Justice Donald Binchy delivered his judgment granting the orders sought by Mr O’Brien and the bank on Thursday afternoon, following a hearing last week lasting more than three days.
It will not be legally possible to report the judge’s reasoning for his decision or his conclusions on the case until at least Friday, June 5th.
Reporting restrictions will remain in place until then, while lawyers from both sides agree on a series of redactions to the version of the written judgment, despite the judge’s reasoning being read to open court yesterday.
RTÉ said it was “disappointed” by the judge’s decision.
“[We] feel that the story is in the public interest, but we respect the court’s decision. RTÉ will give further consideration to today’s ruling and will continue to report on, and investigate, stories in the public interest,” the broadcaster said in a statement.
Public interestIt had argued it should be allowed broadcast information about Mr O’Brien’s banking affairs because it was in the public interest, in the context of a story about the governance of IBRC.
Mr O’Brien, who had argued that he was entitled to his privacy and that his relationships with other banks would be damaged by the report, said he took the case “to protect my rights as a citizen”.
“I believe that every citizen is entitled to privacy in their financial affairs. RTÉ came into possession of highly selective illegally obtained documents and took a decision to attempt to broadcast the details,” he said.
The proposed story was partially based on a letter written by Mr O’Brien to IBRC liquidator Kieran Wallace in 2013 in which he asked for more time to repay his loans, which had expired.
This can be reported because the information was revealed to the Dáil by Independent TD Catherine Murphy, who has expressed concern at the injunction.
Senior counsel Michael Cush, representing Mr O’Brien, told the court during the hearing that the letter contained “precise information regarding his historical debts, the repayments he had made, and the balance” due to the bank.