Report into Project Eagle sale a sharp reminder of price taxpayer paid
Combined losses of €3.55bn incurred by Nama fell mostly on taxpayers’ shoulders
Members of the PAC chaired by Sean Fleming, from left Josepha Madigan Shane Cassells, Alan Farrell and Catherine Connolly on the examination of the NAMA sale of Project Eagle. Photograph: Cyril Byrne
The Committee of Public Accounts (PAC) report into the Project Eagle sale process generated plenty of noise on Monday as the Oireachtas public spending watchdog issued a number of negative findings against Nama for failings when selling its Northern Ireland assets in 2014.
In total, the par value of the loans extended to Northern Ireland borrowers amounted to €5.38 billion at the time of their transfer to Nama in 2010 and 2011. Some 46 per cent or €2.5 billion had been extended by Anglo Irish Bank, with 21 per cent or €1.1 billion by AIB, 30 per cent or €1.6 billion by Bank of Ireland and €180 million by INBS.
Nama valued the loans for acquisition using a methodology agreed with the European Commission. This involved a discount of €2.75 billion being applied to the borrowings, a cost borne largely by taxpayers but also by shareholders in the banks.
A hefty discount of 86 per cent was applied to the loans extended by INBS with the result that they were valued at just €20 million.
In the case of AIB, the discount amounted to 43 per cent, the discount was 50 per cent for Bank of Ireland and 52 per cent for Anglo. This all amounted to Nama paying €2.65 billion for the loans, a figure that would rise to €2.82 billion between 2011 and 2014 for various reasons.
The disposal of Project Eagle to Cerberus generated just more than €1.43 billion, giving rise to a total loss incurred by Nama of €800 million, including a large impairment charge.
Earlier disposals amounted to €590 million, to bring Nama’s total proceeds from its Northern Ireland debtors to €2.02 billion. This amounted to just 36 per cent of the original value of the loans, or combined losses of €3.55 billion.
It’s a stark reminder of the vanity of Irish bankers and property developers during the boom, which has cost taxpayers dearly.