School heads may opt for own union

School principals, most of them members of teacher unions, decided in Galway at the weekend to explore the idea of representing…

School principals, most of them members of teacher unions, decided in Galway at the weekend to explore the idea of representing themselves.

The once all-powerful teachers unions, such as the ASTI and TUI, are facing a powerful internal challenge judging by the atmosphere of frustration at the this weekend's conference of principals and deputy principals.

Both unions are already under severe pressure to deliver for their members on the pay front, but now they are being asked serious questions by the 1,200 members of the National Association of Principals and Deputy Principals (NAPD), which held a highly successful annual conference in Galway.

NAPD is currently strictly a professional association, but could it become more?

READ MORE

The conference passed a motion on Saturday for its executive to carry out a "full exploration and investigation of the organisational and representational structure" of NAPD.

While something of a mouthful, this motion means the executive can now look at all possible options, including breaking away from the teacher unions.

That option remains one of the more drastic ideas at this stage, but if the leaderships of the ASTI and TUI are not careful to nurture their principal and deputy principal members, it could become a realistic possibility.

By submitting their own paper to the Government's benchmarking body recently, NAPD signalled its separation on pay from the general body of teachers and also from the biggest second level union, the ASTI, which is boycotting the benchmarking process.

The wording of their submission is unambiguous about the difference between teachers and principals on pay. It says the approach of the TUI in particular, of submitting a claim for the generality of teachers is mistaken.

"A uniform claim made on behalf of the profession in general completely ignores the subtle, but radical changes that have occurred in the grades of principal and deputy principal," says NAPD's submission.

This is the most crucial part of the submission and the one which causes ASTI and TUI leaders the most distress.

This is because it breaks from the accepted wisdom in teaching, that all teachers are essentially the same, be they principals or non-principals.

This belief is given practical recognition in the "common basic scale" which governs the pay of all teachers, including principals and deputy principals.

Some principals, though far from all, want to break from this and regard themselves as chief executives of medium sized organisations and believe they should be paid accordingly.

NAPD's submission makes this point and adds that the job security, holidays and conditions of work differ totally from those of teaching colleagues.

While it is too early to talk of a breakaway, the Irish principals have been studying the British system where head teachers represent themselves. NAPD's director, Ms Mary McGlynn, told The Irish Times, at the weekend that members would be consulted intensively over the next year on what principals should do next. In their next annual conference the results of this consultation will be announced.