Jury discharged in journalist death-threats case

The jury has been discharged in the trial of a man accused of threatening to kill and cause serious harm to a Sunday World journalist…

The jury has been discharged in the trial of a man accused of threatening to kill and cause serious harm to a Sunday Worldjournalist.

Judge Donagh McDonagh discharged the jury following legal argument at Dublin Circuit Criminal Court. A new date will be set later.

James Walsh (45), of Mountain View Drive, Churchtown, pleaded not guilty to one count of threatening to kill Paul Williams, crime editor of the Sunday World, on June 25th, 2003, and a count of threatening to cause him serious harm later the same day.

Mr Williams told Fergal Foley BL, prosecuting, he wanted to interview Mr Walsh about "a matter" and called to his home where he left his name and contact number.

READ MORE

Mr Williams said he received a call on the morning of June 25th, 2003, from a voice he identified as Mr Walsh's.

The reception was bad and the call was made again some minutes later. He said he was told "if you write anything about me in the Sunday Worldyou will be meeting Veronica Guerin and I mean that".

Mr Williams said he was "terrified" and believed the message "meant one thing". He said he had been threatened on a number of occasions but that his murdered colleague's name had never been mentioned to him before in this context.

Mr Williams said that around 2.20pm he received another phone call from the same voice which said: "I've just been pulled in by your mate (Detective Garda) Joe O'Hara and you won't be walking very much longer."

Defence counsel, John Phelan SC, in cross-examination, presented mobile phone records to the court that detailed calls made to Mr Walsh's 086 mobile phone on the day in question.

He said records also showed that Mr Williams received the alleged threat calls from an 087 number which was in the Ormonde Quay area at 11.38 am and Smithfield at 11.40am.

Records showed Mr Walsh received calls while in the Churchtown area at 11.17am and Terenure at 11.51am.

Mr Phelan said the same 087 number made an unrelated call at 1.45pm from the "Half Way House" mast area in Walkinstown while Mr Walsh was in Sundrive Road Garda Station.

Mr Phelan also said Mr Walsh's 086 number received a call from 2.17pm to 2.24pm from an official Garda phone while he was in Drimnagh. He said Mr Williams received the second alleged threat at 2.18pm from the 087 number, again from the "Half Way House" mast area.

Mr Williams agreed with Mr Phelan's suggestion that it "had to be somebody other than James Walsh" who made the call in the afternoon.

Det Gda O'Hara told Mr Foley that the accused had failed to appear on three previous occasions at Sundrive Road Garda Station for interview.