ESB may face €90m flood bill in wake of court decision
Judge rules that firm 60% liable for €20m damage caused to University College Cork
UCC argued the way the ESB released water from the two hydroelectric dams following heavy rainfall led to unnecessary additional flooding which caused substantial damage. Photograph: Michael MacSweeney/Provision
Mr Justice Max Barrett ruled that the ESB, as the operator of the Inniscarra and Carrigadrohid dams in the Lee Valley, was 60 per cent liable for the estimated €20 million worth of damage caused to University College Cork property in the flood of November 19th, 2009.
The university argued the way the ESB released water from the two hydroelectric dams following heavy rainfall led to unnecessary additional flooding which caused substantial damage.
UCC had brought the claim on behalf its insurer, Aviva, and although the college was found to be 40 per cent liable for the damage through contributory negligence, legal and insurance experts say the judgment opens the way for other insurers to sue the semi-State company.
Private residentsJoe Noonan
According to claims specialist Eamon Downey of the Irish Claims Consultants Association, the ruling opens the way for other insurance companies to seek to recoup from the ESB what they paid out in damages for the Cork flood.
Both Mr Noonan and Mr Downey pointed out that the flood happened on November 19th, 2009, and that the statute of limitations, which prevents claims being brought after six years, does not expire until November 19th next, so claims for damages can still be lodged.
Mr Downey, whose company handled more than 900 individual cases arising from the flood, said many insurance companies would look at the High Court judgment and see it as paving the way for them to sue the ESB.
The court heard Aviva had paid out €34 million in damages arising from the flood and while some €20 million of this relates to damage in UCC, about €14 million relates to other claims made by its clients who suffered flood damage.
It is understood the hospital filed a claim for €1.2 million arising from the damage with Aviva. The insurance company has since lodged a claim for that sum with the ESB and was awaiting the UCC judgment before pursuing it.
Meanwhile, an ESB spokesman said it is insured by an international insurance company.