Stocktake: ‘World seems to be more than 15% screwed up’
Positivity about market bounce may be overplayed in uncertain Covid-19 world
The bounce in indices outside the US has been weaker, and investors are entitled to wonder if American optimism is overdone. Photograph: Michael Nagle/Bloomberg
Marks’s pithy observation encapsulates the reservations of those who see the market rebound as one that has gone too far, too fast.
Bulls can credibly argue a strong rebound was due, given the extent of the March sell-off and the fact that policymakers and central banks have demonstrated a “whatever it takes” attitude. Still, the bounce in indices outside the US has been weaker, and investors are entitled to wonder if American optimism is a little overdone.
Analyst estimates suggest US stocks now trade on their highest forward valuation multiple in 18 years, notes Bloomberg’s John Authers. Additionally, many analysts have been slow to update their earnings estimates, so the true picture may be worse again.
Valuation aside, uncertainty – regarding the economy reopening, the response of consumers, the health outlook as restrictions are lifted – remains at abnormally high levels. It took seven years for markets to regain their 2000 highs in 2007 and 5½ years to get back to their 2007 highs in 2012, says Marks. “Is it really appropriate that, given all the bad news in the world today, we should get back to the highs in only three months? That seems inappropriately positive”.